Two weeks ago, I made the hour and 45-minute haul to the tip of the Door Peninsula, where I queued for the first come, first served car ferry to Washington Island.
As the wind whipped my face during the 30-minute crossing, I considered that it might have been my most elaborate reporting trip.
It culminated in the story we published today on the island’s large contingent of homeschoolers. A fascinating dynamic is unfolding: For the most part, it’s not that homeschooling families have a beef with the local public schools, but their choices add challenges to an already-struggling district. I traced how these modern homeschoolers defy persistent stereotypes while working to coexist alongside public school families.
1 in 4 Washington Island kids are homeschooled. What their stories reveal about a growing trend.
Homeschooling is at a record high in Wisconsin, but families’ reasons for opting out of traditional schools defy stereotypes. On remote Washington Island, homeschoolers and a tiny public school are finding ways to coexist — even as every student matters to the district’s bottom line.
Telling that story meant visiting residents in person, learning details you can’t gather over phone or Zoom.
If I didn’t make the effort to come to their town, look them in the eye, sip coffee with them and explain my interest in their perspectives, I wouldn’t have gained the trust of two of the homeschooling moms in my story.
Because I was there, I saw the district’s administrator banter with a local homeschooling mom who formerly taught at the school — an example of the nuanced relationship between the two camps. I saw the mutual respect between two people who make different choices — not animosity, as one might assume.
Being there allowed me to pick up on other important details, like a banner pleading for donations for a new school gym. It’s small, but it helps readers picture the consequences of the district’s tight budget.
Perhaps most importantly, I wouldn’t have gotten to hold one resident’s duck while visiting her farm.
Showing up allows us to give readers a deeper understanding of Wisconsin’s communities. It’s one of the things Wisconsin Watch does best. I hope you learn something new by reading.

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.

