Click here to read highlights from the story
- Homeschooling has reached a record high in Wisconsin, continuing to grow after a pandemic-era surge as public school enrollment declines and private school enrollment remains flat.
- On remote Washington Island, where 1 in 4 children are homeschooled, families challenge common stereotypes about who homeschools and why — while coexisting with the local public school.
- Most families don’t view homeschooling as a rejection of the local school, and some participate in school classes and extracurricular activities.
- The large share of homeschooled children means lost revenue for the island’s school district, which is trying to entice more families to enroll by making school a place kids want to be.
After years of bouncing around the country, Hannah Dusik was ready to return to the small-town life she knew growing up. So six years ago, she moved back to Washington Island, a community 7 miles off Wisconsin’s Door County peninsula that can only be reached by a 30-minute ferry ride across Lake Michigan.
She and her husband bought a farmhouse on several acres and set about building a hobby farm, where they resolved to homeschool their four children. With ducks, geese, goats, pigs, sheep and cows roaming her property, “I feel like I’m living in a novel … It’s just slow. My kids are safe,” she said.
For years, Dusik was part of an outsized, close-knit community of homeschooling families on the island.
“I think it’s important for people to think that kids also deserve some sense of freedom, and I think that homeschool gives them a little bit of that,” Dusik said, contrasting the experience with traditional schooling.
“Adults don’t even want to work a full-time job. You’re expecting a child who literally doesn’t even know life yet … It’s like, ‘Bye, enjoy your day.’ You’re there all day long.”
About 1 in 4 school-aged kids on the island are homeschooled, creating an unusual relationship between families who opt out of traditional education and the 60-student public school district where every missing student means less state funding to keep the doors open.
Despite that tension, homeschooling families and the district have remained cordial. Most families don’t view their decision to homeschool as rejection of the local school, and some even participate in school-based extracurricular activities or classes.
The dynamics on Washington Island offer a window into a growing trend playing out across Wisconsin and the nation. Homeschooling hit a fever pitch during the COVID-19 pandemic and has become even more popular in recent years. Research shows these families are choosing to keep their kids home for a variety of reasons that may not fit common stereotypes.
“(Many) think that people are homeschooling as this rejection of traditional schooling and particularly traditional public schooling,” said Angela Watson, director of the Johns Hopkins Homeschool Research Lab. “This is much more dynamic than what people give it credit for and that these families are trying to get their needs met for their kids and for their families for particular things.”

Island offers chance to ‘step out of the mainstream’
Island life isn’t for everyone. The grocery store closes at 5:30 p.m. In winter, after the throngs of tourists leave, the ferry may only make two daily trips to the mainland. Getting to and from a doctor’s appointment can be an all-day affair.
But on the 800-person island, everybody knows everybody, said Tim Verboomen, the school district’s administrator — and its curriculum and athletic directors. Drivers wave as you pass them on the two-lane roads. If you slide your car into a ditch during a harsh Wisconsin snowstorm — which you will — the first passerby has rope to pull you out.
“You sacrifice convenience for wholesomeness,” Verboomen said. Many people are drawn to the island because it feels like a place to “step out of the mainstream” and live untraditionally.
That thirst for something different might explain why so many of the island’s families opt out of the traditional education system. There are more than 20 homeschoolers to 60 public school students, far surpassing the average Wisconsin district’s rate of 6%.
It was the island’s solitude that charmed Cheyenne Watkins, who homeschools her four children.
“We wanted to be in a small town,” she said, and “this is as isolated as you’re gonna get.”
There’s no one reason she homeschools. Religion plays a role, as does her fear that staff might talk to her children about topics like gender in ways she disagrees with, she said. She also loves witnessing her children grasp concepts and solve problems. But the biggest draw is the freedom, which allows her to travel with her children to visit family in other states.
Marisa Kehren has her own mix of reasons for homeschooling.
Kehren, who has a teaching degree, says homeschooling has meant being able to travel with her family when her husband’s FBI job took him all over the country. She can teach her kids the Bible and give more individualized attention to her oldest, who has Down syndrome, than she thinks a public school could.
And most of all, homeschooling means spending precious time with her kids.
“The main reason, I guess, that we haven’t sent our kids is because then (they) won’t be hanging out with me,” Kehren said.
All homeschooling families interviewed by Wisconsin Watch echoed these sentiments, largely attributing their decisions to a desire for flexibility and control over how and what their kids learn, rather than discontent with the local school.
Nationwide, more people are making the same choice. Homeschooling grew exponentially in Wisconsin during the pandemic. After a slight drop after the pandemic, the number of students homeschooling has climbed for the last three years, reaching its highest peak since the state began collecting data in 1984. The spike comes as public school enrollment declines and private school enrollment stays flat.
Homeschool families defy stereotypes
As homeschooling becomes more popular, most people’s perceptions haven’t kept up with what the practice actually looks like, said Watson of the Homeschool Research Lab.
“When I say ‘homeschoolers,’ most people are going to think of these really persistent stereotypes: the mom at the kitchen table with all of the kids … They’re very religious, conservative, whatever,” Watson said. “And then there are concerns about, ‘It’s isolationism and indoctrination, and maybe even educational neglect and abuse.’”
Those families do exist, but they’re fringe cases, she said. Her research has found homeschooling families resemble the U.S. population in race and ethnicity, socioeconomic status, education level and geography. Their reasons for homeschooling are just as varied — from concerns about school safety to minority families seeking to center their language or culture, to families simply wanting a different approach.
And it’s a myth that homeschool families keep all their kids at home for their entire childhood, Watson said. Instead, families often move in and out of the public school, trying to stitch together an approach that works best for them.

Kehren said she takes homeschooling “year by year.” When her kids are older, she might send them to school for more advanced instruction. Her daughter, a “social butterfly,” wants to enroll.
“Each kid has their own personality and goals and wishes and dreams, and we take that into consideration and try and work with them in a way where everybody’s at least remotely happy,” she said.
Washington Island homeschooling parents said one of the biggest misconceptions they face from non-homeschoolers is that their children won’t develop social skills if they don’t attend traditional school.
“It’s a lot of, ‘They’re gonna be weird or antisocial,’” Watkins said. “That’s definitely not the case.”
While both the island and homeschooling can be isolating by nature, the concentration of like-minded families in such a small radius creates a close-knit community.
Most Washington Island homeschooling families belong to a single text messaging group. Parents regularly gather to teach their children or do activities together. Homeschooling co-ops — groups of homeschooling families that meet up for shared classes and social activities — are popular in the community nationwide.
“We’re all close,” Dusik said. “We’re all best friends.”

A sticky financial situation
Having so many homeschooled children creates unique financial challenges for the island’s school district.
Because student enrollment is one factor in determining how much state funding Wisconsin schools receive, every student who doesn’t enroll represents money the district could have — and isn’t getting.
The district — like many others — has asked voters to approve referendums to fill budget shortfalls. It also recently crowdfunded for a new gymnasium, hanging banners soliciting donations around the town.
“There’s between a quarter million and a half million dollars out there that we could bring in if we could get those kids into our building,” Verboomen said.
The Washington Island School is small. One building serves all of the island’s students. It’s split into three hallways, each one dedicated to elementary, middle or high school classes and lockers. But there’s room for every school-aged child on the island.
And Verboomen wants them all.
“We could teach twice as many kids as we currently have in our building for almost no additional expense,” Verboomen said. “We have all the teachers paid for already. We already have the lights on. We’re paying for the heat already. We would have to buy more toilet paper, and you know maybe a little more cleaning supplies and whatever, but very minimal expense to get more people in.”
‘I want them to be in school’
As a bobblehead of himself nods on his desk, Verboomen sits across from Kehren, who once taught math at the island school. He tries to convince her to return to teaching and bring her five homeschooled children with her. By now, it’s become a joke between them.
It’s easy for Kehren to laugh off the badgering. She has heard his pleas many times before. But beneath the jokes, Verboomen is serious.
“I have to say that,” he said, “because maybe there’s a chance.”
Teachers are hard to come by on the island, where the remote location and housing costs make recruiting a challenge. Each of the school’s 15 teachers instruct several grade levels or subjects, and they’ve had to look to teachers who don’t meet all of the state’s requirements. Verboomen looks for “good people” he knows and works with them to get emergency licenses, an increasingly common practice statewide.
“We’ll do whatever,” Verboomen said. “I’ve had to be shameless.”
To entice homeschooling families to enroll, staff have focused on making the school a place kids want to be.
But families don’t have to quit homeschooling to show up. By law, the district allows homeschooling families to participate in sports and extracurriculars. Wisconsin state law says public schools must allow homeschoolers to take up to two classes per semester. Schools collect partial funding for the time those students spend in class.
Watkins’ 12-year-old daughter plays on the school’s soccer team and attends school events like dances and dinners. Kehren’s kids participate in chess club and team sports. Sometimes older students sign up for math or science classes that are difficult for parents to teach at a higher level.
“I want their kids to get here and be like, ‘Mom, I want to go back. I want to be here.’ I want them to be in school. That’s my job. It’s just personal, right?” Verboomen said.
But not all district leaders think that’s the right approach, Verboomen said. None of the district’s five board members responded to Wisconsin Watch’s requests for an interview.
“I mostly would believe that if we are a place that they want to be at, that that’s our best chance,” Verboomen said. “But some think that if we are more exclusive … and the only way to get access to the school is to be here, that would get them in.”
As homeschooling grows nationwide, this is a balance more schools are grappling with. Public schools are beginning to understand that homeschool families are “more pragmatic” than the stereotypes tell them, Watson said, and the relationship between the two camps is becoming less “adversarial” as a result. Still, some worry it hurts a school’s culture to have students coming and going, she said.
“Because of necessity, right, (public schools are) changing their attitude a little bit,” Watson said. “It helps the homeschooled students because now they can play football or take chemistry, and it helps the schools because they can recoup some of these students that they would otherwise not be getting funding for.”

One family chooses to enroll
For Hannah Dusik, the decision to homeschool was once easy. As a stay-at-home mom, she wanted to soak up all the moments with her four children she could get.
“To have them be at school with people all day instead of me just was a really hard concept for me to accept,” she said.
Homeschooling allowed Dusik to give each of her kids what they needed. Her 12-year-old, for example, thrives when she can run around in fresh air. If they lived in a bigger town, Dusik said she might have considered a Montessori school focused on hands-on, child-led learning.
“But up here, we have two options. You’re going to the public school, or you are homeschooling,” Dusik said.
But as the years passed, Dusik started struggling. Her kids fought her instruction at every turn, and bickering filled that sacred extra time together. Her son needed more structure. She realized she might not be cut out to be her children’s teacher.
Defeated, she enrolled them in the island’s school.
“I can’t keep them in a bubble, which has been very difficult for me,” she said. “You need to start to let them go a little bit. So these are my baby steps.”
Dusik, who once rejected the notion that school would help her kids’ socialization, has felt “humbled” to see them doing well. Her oldest, a sixth grader with anxiety, has “come out of her shell more” since enrolling. She’s gained confidence — even if she still says she hates school.
Their success has been a hard pill for Dusik to swallow, especially after seeing influencers raving about their idyllic homeschooling lives. “Sometimes it just doesn’t work how you want it to,” Dusik said. “You see the highlights on social media and Instagram, but it just doesn’t always go like that. Even with how badly you want it to.”
Still, she said, she’s not ruling out the possibility of pulling her kids out of the school system in the future.
“I still have the mentality of sticking it to the man. I don’t like the system, like in general,” Dusik said. “I feel like they need more than what I can handle right now. So I’m using these amazing people that I trust as a tool to help us through this season.”

Wisconsin Watch is a nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom. Subscribe to our newsletters for original stories and our Friday news roundup.

