An independent audit is calling for changes in Wisconsin’s school report cards, saying they fall short of providing school performance information required by statute.
The Legislative Audit Bureau, or LAB, issued a 146-page report Friday reviewing school report cards from 2022 through 2025 for public, charter and private schools.
The audit was commissioned by the Republican-led Joint Legislative Audit Committee in February 2025 after DPI changed how the report cards are scored.
LAB made 13 recommendations to DPI and suggested the department report to the Joint Legislative Audit Committee by March 30, 2027 on efforts to implement all of the recommendations.
After receiving the report, Sen. Eric Wimberger, R-Gillett, and Rep. Robert Wittke, R-Caledonia, who chair the audit committee, said “DPI unilaterally turned school report cards into an untrustworthy sham.”
“Accountability is not optional,” Wittke said in a statement. “The Department of Public Instruction must demonstrate that it is putting Wisconsin students, families, and schools ahead of politics and bureaucracy.”
State Superintendent Jill Underly said it is “notable” that the audit is being released the same week school district report cards were issued after months of silence from LAB.
“Let’s be clear: Our job at the DPI is to do what’s best for Wisconsin’s kids and families. The Legislative Audit Bureau’s job is to conduct objective, fact-based audits, and not play politics,” Underly said in a statement.
“This audit offers nothing new,” Underly continued. “The DPI has been transparent throughout this process, participated in multiple public legislative hearings on these issues, and repeatedly answered questions about our work. Instead of providing meaningful new information and recommendations, the audit makes factually incorrect assertions, goes beyond the scope of its review, and reads like a continuation of last legislative session’s partisan political theater rather than a review conducted in good faith.”
Lowest performing schools not receiving intervention
On Tuesday, 95% of Wisconsin public school districts were ranked with three, four or five stars. Those rankings reflect meeting, exceeding or significantly exceeding expectations.
School report cards look at four priority areas for three school years: achievement, growth, target group outcomes and on-track to graduation.
At the same time, test scores released in October showed 48% of students in grades three through 11 were proficient or above in reading while about 49% were proficient or above in math.
Part of the reason for this discrepancy is DPI weighs student achievement and growth more than student performance in calculating overall scores in low income districts.
This methodology was approved by a GOP-led state Legislature and signed into law by former Gov. Scott Walker.
Critics of the state report card say methodology makes it impossible for parents to make apples-to-apples comparisons between districts across the state.
In 2021, a bill was introduced that would have given all four priority areas equal weight.
Gov. Tony Evers vetoed the bill.
In his veto message, Evers said he objected to the Legislature’s “continued efforts to politicize our schools and our classrooms.”
Criticism for state report cards grew louder in 2024, when DPI rolled out new testing standards and updated the “cut scores,” which determine where the schools and districts fall on the star scale.
At the time, Underly said the updates were needed to keep pace with changes to performance measures.
Republicans and outside conservative groups, including the Wisconsin Institute for Law and Liberty and Institute for Reforming Government, have continued to argue the changes lowered standards.
Wimberger said the audit shows DPI “circumvented statutes and lowered cut scores so that otherwise failing schools appear to be on track.”
While the audit released Friday does not specifically say that DPI lowered standards, it found that DPI’s assessment process is not creating conditions for intervention when schools are meeting minimal performance standards.
The percentage of schools meeting, exceeding, or significantly exceeding expectations increased from school year 2022-2023 to school year 2024-2025, and the percentage of schools meeting few expectations or failing to meet expectations decreased from school year 2022-2023 to school year 2024-2025, according to the audit.
The school performance category assigned to most schools and school districts did not change from school year 2023-2024 to school year 2024-2025. However, 20.2% of schools and 21% of school districts moved up one school performance category during that time, the audit found.
The audit also found DPI should have released written policies to all stakeholders about testing changes. The audit says the department did not solicit feedback broadly from educators or members of the public before making changes.
“Although DPI indicated it received informal feedback from stakeholders about changing assessment cut scores through ad hoc conversations and discussions during meetings and presentations, DPI was unable to provide documentation of the feedback it received or how it used the feedback to inform the changes it made,” the audit found.
This story was originally published by WPR.
