A person in a red sweatshirt and cap sits on a couch examining pages in an open binder while another person sits nearby watching.
Al Valentin, right, and Paul Jacobson look through documents on Nov. 16, 2025, in Green Bay as the “Plaster and Patina” podcast team works on ideas for an upcoming episode. Wisconsin Watch reporter Miranda Dunlap got the idea to cover the podcast after seeing a QR code for it while out on a walk. (Mike Roemer for Wisconsin Watch)
Reading Time: < 1 minute

Spoiler alert: There’s no magic formula. 

Wisconsin Watch reporters have to fill out a pitch form for every story. Yes, you read that right – they have to do paperwork. 

The process means they have to do some reporting in advance to make sure the idea is solid, to see if other outlets have reported on the topic and, if so, to determine what will make their story different. 

The goal is for them to have a strong idea about what the story is and who the story is for before they dive in too far. 

Generally, our reporters aren’t covering school board or city council meetings like daily beat reporters. Wisconsin Watch focuses on investigative, enterprise and solutions journalism. Our reporters are looking for trends, sifting through reader tips and finding inspiration in their daily lives.

Miranda Dunlap pitched a story about a Green Bay group that produces a historical podcast about its neighborhood. Do you know where she got the idea? She spotted a QR code advertising the podcast while taking a walk. 

Our journalism strives to live out our mission: using journalism to make Wisconsin communities strong, informed and connected. Every time I read a pitch, I ask myself, “How does this story fit our mission?” 

There are myriad stories we could be chasing, but they’re not all worth our time. The pitch form helps reporters and editors keep our mission in mind and answer key questions before we spend too much energy reporting and editing a story that doesn’t serve our readers.

Sign up for Northeast News, our free email newsletter focused on northeast Wisconsin.

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

Jen Zettel-Vandenhouten joined Wisconsin Watch in August 2025 as regional editor for northeastern Wisconsin. She previously served as managing editor for Project Optimist, a nonprofit news organization focused on greater Minnesota. Jen’s past employers include the Duluth News Tribune, The Post-Crescent (Appleton, Wis.), USA TODAY Network-Wisconsin, and the Watertown Daily Times (Watertown, Wis.). Her teams have been honored with awards from the Minnesota Society of Professional Journalists and the Minnesota and Wisconsin newspaper associations. Jen holds a bachelor’s degree in journalism and English from the University of Wisconsin. She is also an accredited trainer through the Solutions Journalism Network. (Photo by Erica Dischino for Project Optimist)