Thaum Lub Rau Hli 8, 2016, Alfonzo Clayborne thiab nws tus hluas nkauj hu lub tsheb thauj neeg mob vim lawv tus tub hnub nyoog 3 hli tau qaug zog. Kev tsis txaus siab txhaum cai hais tias tus menyuam tau los ntshav ntawm nws lub hlwb thiab pob txha ntawm nws sab laug femur. Clayborne tau raug foob nrog kev raug mob thawj zaug, tab sis tus kws lij choj tau tshem tawm rooj plaub tom qab cov kws tshaj lij hais tias tus menyuam tsis tau tsoo nws txhais ceg thiab qaug dab peg yuav ua rau nws qaug zog. Clayborne tau yees duab hauv Fitchburg, Wis., thaum Lub Kaum Hli 7, 2021. Coburn Dukehart / Wisconsin Saib
Sijhawm Nyeem Ntawv: 7 feeb

Ua ntej kev iab liam kev tsim txom menyuam yaus ua rau nws lub neej poob rau xyoo 2016, Alfonzo Clayborne tau muaj nws thawj txoj haujlwm tau nyiaj ntau thiab chav tsev tshiab hauv Fitchburg, Wisconsin, uas nws thiab nws tsev neeg tshiab tau hloov mus rau hauv tsev. Nws tau yuav nws tus kheej thiab nws tus hluas nkauj txhua lub tsheb.

Lub neej thaum muaj hnub nyoog 22 xyoos tau dhau los ua "ruaj khov," nws hais. 

Qhov ntawd tag nrho ploj mus ib hnub thaum Lub Rau Hli thaum nws pom nws tus tub muaj 3 hlis tsis teb rau hauv nws lub txaj. Nws hu tus me nyuam niam. Nws los tsev los ntawm kev ua hauj lwm, thiab lawv hu ua 9-1-1.

Lub tsheb thauj neeg mob tau coj nws thiab tus menyuam mus rau tsev kho mob. Clayborne taug kev hauv nws lub tsheb. Tab sis thaum nws tuaj txog, cov neeg ua haujlwm ntawm American Family Children's Hospital txwv tsis pub nws koom nrog nws tsev neeg.

Lub tsev kho mob pab neeg tiv thaiv menyuam yaus tau hais rau tub ceev xwm tias tus menyuam muaj lub hlwb los ntshav thiab sab laug ceg tawg. Ib tus kws kho mob tau hais rau tub ceev xwm tias lwm qhov kev raug mob tuaj yeem ua tau tab sis tseem tsis tau lees paub, raws li kev tsis txaus siab txhaum cai.

Dr. Barbara Knox tau tawm hauv University of Wisconsin thiab American Family Children's Hospital hauv 2019 tom qab cov npoj yaig yws yws txog kev thab plaub hauv chaw ua haujlwm thiab cov niam txiv tau liam tias nws kuaj pom kev tsim txom. Nws tau raug ntiav los ntawm Alaska CARES, lub tsev kho mob kev tsim txom menyuam yaus thoob plaws lub xeev hauv Anchorage, qhov chaw uas nws tau tshaj tawm tias nws tau raug tso tseg rau kev tshawb nrhiav. University of Wisconsin-Madison

Tom qab ntawd-tus kws kho mob tus thawj coj Dr. Barbara Knox tau kuaj thiab kuaj tus menyuam mos. Nws tus kws kho mob pab, Amanda Palm, tau xa Knox qhov kev kuaj mob rau tub ceev xwm thiab hais rau lawv tias tus menyuam raug mob yog tshwm sim los ntawm kev raug mob.

Cov tub ceev xwm tsom mus rau Clayborne. Ib tug tub ceev xwm thiab tus neeg ua haujlwm tiv thaiv menyuam yaus tau xam phaj nws. Tus neeg ua haujlwm tiv thaiv menyuam yaus yog thawj tus qhia nws xov xwm ntawm nws tus tub tus mob. 

Clayborne tau hais tias "Lawv hais tias nws tau tawg ceg, lossis ceg ceg tawg, qee qhov nqaij ntuag thiab pob txha taub hau tawg," Clayborne nco qab. “Thiab kuv zoo li, 'Tsis muaj txoj hauv kev.' ”

Tus neeg ua haujlwm CPS nug nws seb nws puas ntaus tus menyuam, nws hais tias, thiab hais txog cov xwm txheej qhia tias Clayborne tau ua phem rau tus menyuam los ntawm kev ntxhov siab. Lawv muab nws txoj kev xaiv tsis txaus ntseeg: Nws tus hluas nkauj tau raug mob tus menyuam, lossis nws muaj. Clayborne teb tias: "Nws yog kuv."

"Qhov xwm txheej tau dhau mus, thiab kuv tsuas yog sim ua kom nws dhau mus. Kuv tsis paub tias kuv yuav raug foob, "nws hais.

Tus me nyuam tau tawm hauv tsev kho mob nrog lub cam khwb cia ntawm nws txhais ceg rau kev so uas nws hloov tawm tias nws tsis tau muaj.

Xya hnub tom qab, Clayborne tau tawm hauv tub ceev xwm chaw nres tsheb nrog lub pob taws saib xyuas thiab raug foob txhaum cai ntawm kev raug mob thawj zaug - tom qab poob qis tom qab cov kws tshaj lij tau txiav txim siab sib txawv ntau dua li Knox.

Knox ib zaug ua tim khawv tias nws yeej tsis tau ua yuam kev hauv kev kuaj xyuas menyuam yaus. Tab sis Clayborne cov ntaub ntawv yog ib qho ntawm ntau qhov kev tshuaj xyuas los ntawm Wisconsin Watch nyob rau hauv uas Knox qhov kev kuaj mob ntawm kev tsim txom menyuam yaus tau coj mus rau kev foob tias lub txim txhaum cai lij choj thaum kawg tsis lees paub. Wisconsin Watch ua ntej tshaj tawm txog cov kev paub dhau los ntawm xya pawg ntawm cov niam txiv uas raug tshawb xyuas - tab sis tsis raug them - rau kev tsim txom menyuam yaus thaum tsis muaj.

Hauv ob qhov xwm txheej, cov neeg saib xyuas tau ua haujlwm hauv tsev loj cuj hauv cov xwm txheej uas tau tsim los ntawm Knox. Jennifer Hancock ntawm Verona tab tom ua haujlwm rau 13-xyoo kab lus cuam tshuam nrog kev tuag ntawm tus menyuam mos hauv nws qhov kev saib xyuas. Nws tau thov nws rooj plaub mus rau lub Wisconsin Lub Tsev Hais Plaub Hais Kom Saib Dua. Joshua Gehde ntawm Madison tab tom raug kaw 20 xyoo tom qab nws tus hluas nkauj tus menyuam me tuag thaum Gehde tab tom saib xyuas nws. Gehde tau thov nws rooj plaub tsis ua tiav thiab tab tom xav txog lwm qhov kev thov rov hais dua.

Cov tsev neeg thiab cov tib neeg tuaj tom ntej los qhia lawv cov dab neeg tom qab ib 2020 Wisconsin Watch kev tshawb nrhiav qhia tias Knox tau yuam kev yuam kev rau Mount Horeb ob peb ntawm kev ua phem rau lawv tus tub 9 hli. 

UW tau ncua Knox hauv 2019 rau kev thab plaub nws cov neeg ua haujlwm. Nws tawm xyoo ntawd los ua tus thawj coj kho mob ntawm Alaska CARES, lub tsev kho mob kev tsim txom menyuam yaus thoob plaws lub xeev. Knox tau tshaj tawm tias tau tso tseg los ntawm lub chaw Anchorage, uas tau pom kev khiav tawm ntawm cov neeg ua haujlwm coob leej uas hais tias Knox thab plaub lawv thiab tau hais lus tsis raug cai ntawm kev tsim txom menyuam yaus, raws li ib tug sib koom Wisconsin Watch/Anchorage Daily News tshawb nrhiav.

Knox tsis teb rau ntau qhov kev thov xam phaj, hu xov tooj thiab emailed daim ntawv teev cov kev tshawb pom.

'Kuv raug nyiag thiab nyiag'

Ib lub lis piam tom qab Clayborne tau haum nrog lub pob taws saib xyuas, tus kws kho mob orthopedist hais rau tus me nyuam niam nws tus tub tsis tau muaj pob txha, tab sis "ib txwm txawv ntawm qhov distal femur," raws li cov ntaub ntawv hauv tsev hais plaub.

Txawm hais tias qhov kev tshawb pom no, lub zog ntawm kev ua phem txhaum cai snowballed. 

Thaum Clayborne tus kws lij choj, Bill Jones, sim ua tsis tiav rau ntau lub hlis kom tau txais Knox cov ntaub ntawv kho mob los ntawm kev foob lossis nrhiav seb puas tau npaj, Clayborne raug ntes dua tom qab nws pom muaj tshuaj maj. Qhov raug ntes tau ua txhaum cai ntawm nws qhov kev tso cai rau tus nqi tsim txom menyuam yaus uas tom qab raug pov thawj tias tsis muaj tseeb, thiab Clayborne tau siv sijhawm xya lub lis piam tom ntej ntawm Dane County Jail raug foob nrog suav ntxiv, kev foob txhaum cai dhia.

Alfonzo Clayborne raug foob rau thawj-degree tsis zoo raug mob rau nws tus tub muaj 3 hlis, raws li kev xav ntawm University of Wisconsin Dr. Barbara Knox tias tus tub hluas muaj ib ceg pob txha "los ntawm kev ua nruj ua tsiv lossis ntswj." Cov nqi them tom qab tau muab tso tseg tom qab cov kws tshaj lij tau txiav txim siab tias tus tub sab ceg tsis tawg. Clayborne tau yees duab hauv Fitchburg, Wis., thaum Lub Kaum Hli 7, 2021. Coburn Dukehart / Wisconsin Saib

Thaum nyob hauv kev saib xyuas, Clayborne poob nws txoj haujlwm, nws lub tsheb thiab raug ntiab tawm ntawm nws chav tsev tshiab. Thiab nws tsis nco txog qhov tseem ceeb hauv nws tus tub lub neej, zoo li nws thawj Christmas.

“Thaum kuv mus rau hauv tsev kaw neeg, nws tsis taug kev. Thaum kuv tawm hauv tsev kaw neeg, nws hais lus thiab taug kev, ”Clayborne hais. “Kuv xav tias zoo li kuv raug nyiag lawm, qhov tseem ceeb. Kuv raug nyiag thiab nyiag lawm. Kuv thawj txoj haujlwm uas tau them nyiaj siab, ua qhov zoo, tau txais nce. (Ces) qhov no tshwm sim. "

Raws li Jones qhov kev thov, tus kws kho mob neurologist Dr. Joseph Scheller tau saib Clayborne tus tub cov ntaub ntawv thiab txiav txim siab qaug dab peg tshwm sim los ntawm kev khaus ntawm tus menyuam lub hlwb cov ntaub so ntswg yuav ua rau tus menyuam tsis tsaug zog rau hnub ntawm qhov xwm txheej. "Cov menyuam mos uas raug tsim txom ntawm lub taub hau raug mob feem ntau pom tias muaj kev raug mob sab nraud, cov pob txha tawg, mob caj dab, pob txha pob txha, thiab mob hlwb," Scheller tau sau hauv nws tsab ntawv ceeb toom. "(Tus me nyuam mos) tsis muaj cov no."

Cov ntaub ntawv kho mob tshiab tau ua rau Dane County Tus Lwm Thawj Coj Tus Kws Lij Choj Rachel Sattler, nyob rau lub Tsib Hlis 2017 - ze li ib xyoos tom qab Clayborne raug ntes - thov tsab ntawv txiav txim. Tab sis thaum ntawd, Clayborne lub neej ruaj khov twb tawg lawm. Nws tseem nce toj tawm hauv qab lub pob zeb tawg.

Clayborne tab tom muaj teeb meem tau txais qhov chaw tshiab nyob nrog kev tshem tawm ntawm nws cov ntaub ntawv. Tam sim no nws siv sijhawm ntau npaum li nws tuaj yeem ua tau zoo nrog nws tus tub muaj hnub nyoog 5 xyoos, uas kawm tau zoo hauv tsev kawm ntawv thiab tsis ntev los no yeej tau txais khoom plig rau kev ncaws pob.

Jones tau hais tias cov kws kho mob thiab cov tub ceev xwm tau ceev cov kev xav txog nws cov neeg siv khoom. Nws hu ua ntu "npau suav phem" rau Clayborne.

"Qhov teeb meem yog cov pov thawj kho mob tsis thim rov qab ib qho ntawm qhov ntawd. Lawv zoo li tsis quav ntsej nws, ”Jones hais. “Lawv mus nrog 'Cov niam txiv npau taws poob siab thiab ua rau menyuam yaus mob.' ”

Poob stairs ua rau raug nqi 

Clayborne tsis yog tib tus neeg uas nws lub neej tau hloov kho tom qab raug foob txhaum cai nrog kev tsim txom menyuam yaus tom qab kev ntsuam xyuas los ntawm Knox. 

Hauv Nroog Jefferson, tus kws txiav txim plaub tau txiav txim siab tias ib qho kev foob tsis txaus ntseeg tias nws tau xaus qhov kev txiav txim ua ntej tus kws lij choj txawm hais rau nws rooj plaub. 

Hauv xyoo 2016, tus kws saib xyuas menyuam yaus Lake Mills poob rau ntawm tus ntaiv thaum tuav tus menyuam muaj 4 hli. Tus me nyuam tau txais lub tshuab rau lub taub hau, uas luv luv ua rau nws tsis nco qab, thaum tus neeg zov me nyuam tau raug mob me. Tom qab kev soj ntsuam pom tus menyuam tau los ntshav ntawm nws lub hlwb thiab hemorrhaging hauv nws lub qhov muag, Knox tshaj tawm tias nws ua phem rau lub taub hau, thiab tus poj niam raug foob rau qhov ua rau tus menyuam raug mob.

Dr. Joseph Scheller, tus kws kho mob hlwb hauv Maryland thiab kws kho mob kis kab mob, ua pov thawj rau kev tiv thaiv ntawm Dane County Courthouse hauv Madison, Wis., thaum Lub Kaum Ib Hlis 11, 2021 thaum lub sij hawm sim Kathryn Campbell ntawm Stoughton tom qab muaj 4 hli. tus me nyuam hauv nws txoj kev saib xyuas tau pom tias muaj ntshav ncig nws lub hlwb. Tom qab tsib hnub mus sib hais, pawg neeg txiav txim txiav txim Campbell ntawm kev tsim txom menyuam yaus tom qab ob teev ntawm kev txiav txim siab. Coburn Dukehart / Wisconsin Saib

Tab sis xyoo 2018 mus sib hais hauv Jefferson County Circuit Court tau xaus tam sim ntawd tom qab qhov kev foob tau hais tawm nws cov lus sib cav, suav nrog cov lus pov thawj los ntawm Knox tias cov kev raug mob tau txhob txwm ua rau raug mob thiab tsis yog los ntawm kev poob.

Tus kws lij choj tau txav mus rau tshem tawm rooj plaub, hais tias tsis muaj pov thawj, thiab tus kws txiav txim plaub ntug Jennifer Weston pom zoo. Weston pom tias lub xeev tau ua tsis tiav los qhia tias tus neeg saib xyuas tus cwj pwm ua rau raug mob li cas - lossis nws tsis ua li cas.

Scheller tau zaum hauv lub tsev hais plaub tos chav npaj ua tim khawv rau kev tiv thaiv thaum lub rooj sib hais raug tso tseg. Nws nco qab cov pab pawg ntawm cov neeg caij maus taus tau mob siab rau kev tawm tsam kev tsim txom menyuam yaus uas tuaj koom los txhawb kev foob. Cov neeg caij tsheb kauj vab tau tshaj tawm "kev kub ntxhov" ntawm kev tawm tsam tom qab tus kws txiav txim plaub tau pov qhov rooj plaub, nws hais. 

Scheller tau hais tias "Txhua yam tuaj yeem tshwm sim los ntawm dov (hauv qab ntaiv)," Scheller hais txog qhov kev foob. "Nws yog qhov tsis txaus ntseeg."

Tus neeg zov me nyuam tsis kam tham nrog Wisconsin Watch, hais txog kev qias neeg, kev hem thiab kev saib xyuas pej xeem nws tseem ntsib tom qab raug liam tias yog neeg tsim txom menyuam yaus. Nws thov kom tsis txhob muaj npe.

Tus neeg zov me nyuam raug zam

Tsis ntev los no, thaum Lub Kaum Ib Hlis 11, ib pawg neeg txiav txim hauv Dane County raug txim Stoughton tus kws saib xyuas menyuam yaus Kathryn Campbell ntawm kev tsim txom me nyuam tsis zoo ua rau raug mob tom qab tsuas yog ob teev ntawm kev sib tham. Knox tau ua txhaum cai hauv 2017 thaum nws hais rau tub ceev xwm tus menyuam hnub nyoog 4 hlis hauv Campbell txoj kev saib xyuas raug kev txom nyem los ntawm "kev tsim txom menyuam yaus pom tseeb." 

Scheller, ua pov thawj rau kev tiv thaiv, hais tias tus menyuam, uas tam sim no noj qab nyob zoo 4 xyoo, muaj mob uas ua rau nws los ntshav ncig lub hlwb.

Kathryn Campbell puag nws tus txiv Steven Campbell tom qab hnov ​​​​qhov kev txiav txim tsis muaj txim txhaum hauv nws qhov kev sim ua txhaum cai ntawm Dane County Courthouse hauv Madison, Wis., thaum Lub Kaum Ib Hlis 12, 2021. Campbell raug pom tias tsis muaj kev txhaum ntawm kev foob ntawm 4 lub hlis- laus nyob rau hauv nws tu. Yav tas los University of Wisconsin Dr. Barbara Knox tau teem sijhawm los ua "tus tim khawv tseem ceeb" hauv qhov kev sim siab, tab sis tus foob tau tshem nws lub npe ntawm daim ntawv teev cov neeg tim khawv. Coburn Dukehart / Wisconsin Saib

Knox tau teem sijhawm los ua "tus tim khawv tseem ceeb" hauv Campbell mus sib hais, tab sis qhov kev foob tau tshem nws lub npe los ntawm daim ntawv teev cov pov thawj, thiab tus kws txiav txim plaub Susan Crawford tau hais kom ob tog tsis txhob hais txog nws qhov kev tshawb pom.

Scheller tshwj xeeb hauv kev tsim txom lub taub hau raug mob thiab tau tshuaj xyuas cov ntaub ntawv hauv ntau dua 500 tus neeg mob thiab ua pov thawj ntau dua 250 ntawm lawv. Nws tsis siv rooj plaub uas nws xav tias yuav yog kev tsim txom menyuam yaus.

Thoob plaws hauv lub tebchaws, tsawg kawg 25 tus neeg raug txim los ntawm kev raug mob taub hau lossis nws cov subcategory, shaken baby syndrome, tau raug tshem tawm txij li xyoo 1992 - tsib ntawm lawv hauv 2021 ib leeg, raws li National Registry of Exonerations. Ib qho ntawm cov xwm txheej siab tshaj plaws koom nrog Audrey Edmunds, ib lub nroog Waunakee, Wisconsin, tus kws saib xyuas menyuam yaus thiab leej niam ntawm peb tus uas tau raug kaw 12 xyoo rau kev raug txim rau menyuam yaus hais tias lub Xeev Lub Tsev Hais Plaub Txiav Txim Siab tau muab tso rau hauv 2008.

Scheller tau hais hauv nws qhov kev paub dhau los, thaum tus kws kho mob ua phem rau menyuam yaus tau ua txhaum, tsis muaj kev lav phib xaub. 

Nws tau hais tias "Koj muaj lub zog los ua kom puas tsuaj ntau rau tus neeg tsis muaj txim," nws hais. "Koj tsuas yog yuav tsum ceev faj nrog lub zog ntawd."

Cov Nyiaj Pab rau Kev Tshawb Fawb Kev Tshawb Fawb tau muab kev txhawb nqa nyiaj txiag rau zaj dab neeg no. Wisconsin Watch Managing Editor Dee J. Hall tau pab qhia zaj dab neeg no. Lub koom haum saib xyuas tsis tau nyiaj Wisconsin (www.WisconsinWatch.org) koom tes nrog WPR, PBS Wisconsin, lwm cov xov xwm tshaj tawm thiab University of Wisconsin-Madison Tsev Kawm Ntawv Xov Xwm thiab Kev Sib Txuas Lus. Txhua yam haujlwm tau tsim, tshaj tawm, tshaj tawm lossis tshaj tawm los ntawm Wisconsin Watch tsis tas yuav cuam tshuam cov kev xav lossis kev xav ntawm UW-Madison lossis ib qho ntawm cov koom tes.

Rov luam tawm peb cov ntawv dawb, hauv online lossis luam tawm, raws li daim ntawv tso cai Creative Commons.

Nrov dab neeg los ntawm Wisconsin Watch

Brenda Wintrode / Wisconsin SaibRoy W. Howard tus khub

Brenda Wintrode tau koom nrog Lub Chaw hauv Lub Xya Hli 2021 ua tus phooj ywg Roy W. Howard. Nws yog neeg nyob hauv Shrewsbury, Massachusetts, thiab tau txais nws daim bachelor's degree hauv kev tswj hwm kev lag luam ntawm Bryant University hauv Rhode Island. Tom qab hloov txoj haujlwm los ntawm nyiaj txiag, nws tau raug hu ua Philip Merrill College of Journalism tus kws tshaj lij cov tub ntxhais kawm thaum nws kawm tiav xyoo 2020. Raws li tus kws sau xov xwm rau Howard Center, Wintrode yog tus thawj coj sau ntawv ntawm kev tshawb nrhiav tau txais txiaj ntsig ntawm tsoomfwv CARES Txoj Cai tsis ua tiav. tiv thaiv kev ntiab tawm thaum muaj kev sib kis. Nws kuj yog tus kws tshaj xov xwm tseem ceeb ntawm lub chaw tshawb fawb txog kev tsis muaj tsev nyob, sau tseg tias lub nroog tau kho cov neeg nyob hauv cov chaw pw hav zoov li cas. Nws them rau Maryland xeev tsoomfwv rau Peev Xov Xwm Kev Pabcuam thiab tau ua cov ntaub ntawv txheeb xyuas rau Maryland Matters.