Kathryn Campbell thiab tus kws lij choj tiv thaiv Nathan Otis tawm tsam Campbell qhov tsis txhaum qhov kev txiav txim hauv nws qhov kev sim ua txhaum cai ntawm Dane County Courthouse, hauv Madison, Wis., thaum Lub Kaum Ib Hlis 12, 2021. Campbell raug pom tias tsis muaj txim txhaum ntawm qhov kev foob ntawm 4 lub hlis. - laus nyob rau hauv nws tu. Coburn Dukehart / Wisconsin Saib
Sijhawm Nyeem Ntawv: 5 feeb

Dane County pawg neeg txiav txim plaub ntug rau hnub Friday yav tsaus ntuj tsis lees txais qhov kev tshaj tawm txog kev tsim txom menyuam yaus los ntawm yav dhau los University of Wisconsin tus kws kho menyuam yaus uas tau tawm hauv huab cua tsis sib haum xeeb xyoo 2019, nrhiav tus kws kho mob Stoughton tsis ua txhaum ntawm kev ua phem rau tus menyuam muaj 4 hlis hauv nws qhov kev saib xyuas hauv 2017. .

Tom qab kev sim tsib hnub uas muaj cov lus pov thawj kho mob nyuaj, pawg neeg txiav txim txiav txim siab tsuas yog ob teev rau hnub Friday ua ntej txiav txim rau Kathryn Campbell, 37, ntawm kev tsim txom menyuam yaus uas ua rau raug mob. Ua tim khawv hauv nws tus kheej tiv thaiv, Campbell, uas tau raug kaw rau hauv tsev loj cuj mus txog rau xyoo, rov tsis kam ua phem rau tus menyuam, uas tam sim no muaj 4 xyoos thiab noj qab nyob zoo.

Qhov kev sim siab nyob ib puag ncig kev tsim txom lub taub hau, ib qho teeb meem kev kuaj mob uas tau polarized lub zej zog kho mob. Cov xwm txheej no feem ntau cuam tshuam nrog cov menyuam mos uas tsis muaj pob lossis nqaij tawv ntawm lub taub hau lossis pob txha taub hau tab sis leej twg raug mob lub hlwb uas qee tus kws kho mob ua rau cuam tshuam lossis tshee.

Qhov teeb meem txhaum cai tawm tsam Campbell tau tshaj tawm xyoo 2017 tom qab Dr. Barbara Knox - tus yuam sij tab sis tsis muaj npe nyob rau hauv qhov kev sim - tshaj tawm los ntshav ncig tus menyuam lub hlwb yog "kev tsim txom menyuam yaus pom tseeb." Knox yav dhau los tau coj UW's Child Protection Program hauv kev koom tes nrog American Family Children's Hospital hauv Madison. Nws raug tso tawm hauv 2019 rau kev thab plaub rau cov npoj yaig. Alaska CARES, lub tsev kho mob Anchorage uas ntsuas cov menyuam yaus thoob plaws lub xeev rau kev tsim txom, tau ntiav nws sai sai tom qab ntawd. 

Dr. Barbara Knox yog duab ntawm nplooj Facebook ntawm Ismael Ozanne, Dane County Tus Kws Lij Choj Hauv Cheeb Tsam, hauv kev tshaj tawm Lub Kaum Hli 11, 2016. Knox qhov kev tshawb pom ntawm kev tsim txom menyuam yaus ua rau Stoughton, Wis., tus kws saib xyuas menyuam yaus Kathryn Campbell raug foob txhaum cai. Ib pawg neeg txiav txim plaub ntug hauv Dane tau pom tias Campbell tsis ua txhaum thaum Lub Kaum Ib Hlis 12, 2021. Ismael Ozanne Dane County Cheeb Tsam Tus Kws Lij Choj Facebook nplooj ntawv

Xyoo 2020, Wisconsin Watch tau nthuav tawm qhov ntawd Knox tau liam txhaum rau Mount Horeb, Wisconsin, ob peb xyoos hauv 2019 ntawm kev ua rau lawv tus tub muaj 9 hli raug mob, hais txog bruises ntawm tus menyuam lub cev. Tab sis qee qhov ntawm cov qhab nia yog cov caws pliav thiab lwm tus yog qhov nqaij ntshiv vim tus me nyuam yaus tsoo thiab qw thaum cov neeg ua haujlwm hauv tsev kho mob thiab tus menyuam niam tau tawm tsam los tuav nws kom ntxig ib rab koob rau hauv nws cov leeg thiab muab ib lub catheter rau hauv nws lub puab tsaig.

Knox tau teem sijhawm los ua "tus tim khawv tseem ceeb" hauv Campbell mus sib hais, tab sis tus foob tau tshem nws lub npe los ntawm daim ntawv teev cov neeg ua pov thawj, thiab tus kws txiav txim plaub Susan Crawford tau hais kom ob tog tsis txhob hais txog nws qhov kev tshawb pom lossis daim ntawv foob Knox xa mus rau tus foob cuaj. hli tom qab kuaj tus menyuam mos. 

Cov ntaub ntawv hauv tsev hais plaub qhia tau hais tias kev tiv thaiv tau nrhiav teeb meem ntawm Knox txoj kev qhuab qhia keeb kwm ntawm UW los ntawm kev thov cov ntaub ntawv "txog rau Dr. Knox txoj kev tshaj lij, kev ncaj ncees, kev ncaj ncees thiab kev muaj peev xwm kho mob." 

Ib tus kws tshaj lij ua pov thawj rau Campbell tau hais tias los ntshav hauv nqe lus nug rau ntau qhov chaw nruab nrab ntawm tus menyuam lub hlwb thiab pob txha taub hau uas tso cai rau cov kua dej sib sau ua ke thiab ua rau lub hlwb. Ib tus neeg foob foob tau tsis txaus siab tias, thiab lwm tus kws tshaj lij uas tau hu los ntawm lub xeev tau tuav qhov kev tshawb pom tau "muaj feem cuam tshuam rau kev raug mob taub hau." Cov kws tshaj lij ntawm ob sab hu ua nws tsis yooj yim sua kom paub meej hnub lub hlwb los ntshav ntawm qhov teeb meem. 

Thoob plaws hauv lub tebchaws, tsawg kawg 25 tus neeg raug txim los ntawm kev raug mob taub hau lossis nws cov subcategory, shaken baby syndrome, tau raug tshem tawm txij li xyoo 1992 - tsib ntawm lawv hauv 2021 ib leeg, raws li National Registry of Exonerations. Ib qho ntawm cov xwm txheej siab tshaj plaws koom nrog Audrey Edmunds, ib tug Waunakee, Wisconsin tus kws saib xyuas menyuam yaus thiab leej niam ntawm peb tus uas tau raug kaw 12 xyoo rau qhov kev txiav txim siab me me hais tias lub Xeev Lub Tsev Hais Plaub Txiav Txim Siab tau muab tso rau hauv 2008.

Lub xeev tau them nyiaj rau Campbell tom qab tus menyuam mos hauv nws qhov kev saib xyuas hauv tsev tau pom tias muaj cov hematoma subdural, lossis sau cov ntshav, ntawm lub hlwb.

Kev foob ua yeeb yaj kiab ntawm kev sib tham ntawm Brandon Hill, tus neeg tshawb nrhiav nrog Stoughton Tub Ceev Xwm Lub Tsev Haujlwm, thiab Kathryn Campbell thaum Campbell qhov kev sim siab ntawm Dane County Courthouse, hauv Madison, Wis., thaum Lub Kaum Ib Hlis 10, 2021. Ib pawg neeg txiav txim txiav txim siab Campbell rau Lub Kaum Ib Hlis 12, 2021 ntawm tus nqi tsim txom menyuam yaus. Coburn Dukehart / Wisconsin Saib

Campbell tau ua tim khawv tias tus me nyuam tau sawv los ntawm ib tug pw tsaug zog thaum Lub Yim Hli 24, 2017 nrog "kev quaj qw uas kuv tsis tau hnov ​​dua li." Campbell tau hais tias nws nqa tus menyuam los nplawm nws li 5 mus rau 7 feeb, thaum nws muab tus menyuam tso rau hauv pem teb kom tsis txhob hle nws, tus menyuam lub taub hau poob rov qab thiab ntaus hauv pem teb. "Kuv tsis txhawb nqa nws lub taub hau zoo li kuv yuav tsum muaj," nws ua tim khawv. 

Campbell tau hais tias, "Tom qab ntawd kuv pom tias nws ua pa tau hloov pauv," piav qhia tus menyuam tias "ces" thiab "tso tseg." Nws hu 9-1-1, tab sis thawj tus neeg teb tau txiav txim siab tsis nqa tus menyuam mos mus rau tsev kho mob. Tom qab hnub ntawd, tus me nyuam niam txiv coj nws mus rau kev ntsuam xyuas, ua rau pom cov ntshav ncig nws lub hlwb. 

Campbell pheej tsis kam ua kom raug mob rau tus menyuam, uas kuj muaj qhov nqaij me me pom ua ntej ntawm nws txhais tes thiab xib teg. Campbell tau hais tias qhov kev raug mob tuaj yeem tshwm sim los ntawm nws tus ntxhais, uas yog "tus me nyuam mos" thaum lub sijhawm.

'Pattern' qhia txog kev tsim txom

Ib tug kws tshaj lij uas tau ntiav los ntawm lub xeev, tus kws kho menyuam yaus raug tsim txom Dr. Nancy Harper ntawm Lub Chaw Saib Xyuas Kev Nyab Xeeb thiab Kev Noj Qab Haus Huv ntawm University of Minnesota Masonic Children's Hospital hauv Minneapolis, tau ua pov thawj tias qhov nqaij ntshiv ntawm tus menyuam yog "patterned" kev raug mob uas qhia tias kev nyem los ntawm ib qho. neeg laus tes. Harper kuj tau sau ib sab plhu ntawm lwm tus menyuam hauv Campbell qhov kev saib xyuas hnub; Campbell tau hais tias kev raug mob tuaj yeem tshwm sim los ntawm nws tus ntxhais ntaus tus menyuam nrog cov khoom ua si yas hnyav.

Harper hais tias, "Cov menyuam mos tsis tshua muaj qhov tawv nqaij, thiab qhov tseeb, peb muaj ib lo lus hais tias yog tias koj tseem hluas dhau mus caij nkoj, koj tseem hluas dhau los ua pob," Harper hais, hais txog cov menyuam yaus uas tseem tsis tau nkag, rub lossis taug kev. 

Hais txog qhov nqaij ntshiv thiab lub hlwb raug mob, Harper tau ua tim khawv, "Nws yog kuv lub tswv yim tias qhov no muaj kev cuam tshuam loj heev rau kev raug mob taub hau."

Dr. Joseph Scheller, kws kho mob rau menyuam yaus hauv Maryland, ua pov thawj rau kev tiv thaiv ntawm Dane County Courthouse, hauv Madison, Wis., thaum Lub Kaum Ib Hlis 11, 2021 thaum lub sijhawm sim Kathryn Campbell, uas raug foob rau kev tsim txom menyuam yaus. Pawg neeg txiav txim txiav txim rau Campbell thaum Lub Kaum Ib Hlis 12, 2021. Coburn Dukehart / Wisconsin Saib
Dr. Nancy Harper, tus thawj coj ntawm Center for Safe and Healthy Children ntawm University of Minnesota Masonic Children's Hospital, ua tim khawv rau kev foob rau lub Kaum Ib Hlis 10, 2021 thaum lub sij hawm sim Kathryn Campbell. Harper muaj ntawv pov thawj hauv kev tsim txom menyuam yaus. Coburn Dukehart / Wisconsin Saib

Tus kws tshaj lij kws lij choj Dr. Joseph Scheller, kws kho mob rau menyuam yaus los ntawm Baltimore, tau ua pov thawj qhov kev raug mob ntawm tus menyuam mos lub hlwb tsis tuaj yeem sau hnub tim, qhov taw qhia uas Harper thiab lwm tus kws tshaj lij raug foob kuj lees paub. Scheller kuj tau ua pov thawj tias tus menyuam muaj qhov mob "zoo" - chav ntxiv thiab cov kua dej ntawm nws lub hlwb thiab pob txha taub hau - uas zoo li lwm yam mob hnyav tuaj yeem "ua phem."

Scheller tau hais tias "Muaj cov xwm txheej uas twb muaj lawm uas tuaj yeem ua rau tus menyuam mos raug mob, yam tsis muaj kev tsim txom menyuam yaus - thiab raug mob - ua rau tus menyuam mos raug mob subdural hematoma," Scheller tau hais. "Kuv tsis pom muaj pov thawj tias subdural hematoma yog ib yam khoom ntawm kev tsim txom menyuam yaus, tshee lossis cuam tshuam lossis lwm yam."

Scheller kuj tau ua tim khawv tias tus me nyuam tau ua kom lub taub hau loj hlob raws li qhov nws tau piav qhia. 

Ua pov thawj rau lub xeev, tus kws kho mob neuroradiologist so haujlwm laus Dr. Richard Patterson ntawm Minnesota tau tawm tsam tias tus menyuam muaj tus mob Scheller tau piav qhia. Patterson tau hais tias nws tau pom cov menyuam yaus uas muaj tus mob no "tseem ceeb txhua hnub" hauv nws qhov kev coj ua thiab nws tsis pom nws hauv cov duab ntawm 4-hli lub hlwb. 

Kathryn Campbell tau pom tom qab nws ua pov thawj hauv nws tus kheej tiv thaiv ntawm Dane County Courthouse, hauv Madison, Wis., thaum Lub Kaum Ib Hlis 12, 2021 thaum nws mus sib hais rau qhov raug liam tias ua phem rau tus menyuam mos hauv nws qhov kev saib xyuas. Nws tau pom nrog kws lij choj tiv thaiv Nathan Otis thiab Paisley Hoffman. Pawg neeg txiav txim pom Campbell tsis ua txhaum tom qab hnub ntawd. Coburn Dukehart / Wisconsin Saib

Kev tuav rooj plaub rau lub xeev yog Tus Kws Lij Choj Hauv Cheeb Tsam Carl Lazarus thiab Brian Holmgren, ib tug qub Davidson County, Tennessee tus kws lij choj raug rho tawm haujlwm hauv 2015 thiab tau ntiav ua ntej lub xyoo no los ntawm Dane County District Attorney's Office rau $150,000 txog 2026 los foob cov teeb meem kev tsim txom menyuam yaus. Ob leeg tsis kam tawm tswv yim txog kev txiav txim plaub ntug. 

Campbell zoo siab heev tau hais tias nws "zoo siab heev, nws dhau lawm." 

Madison kws lij choj Paisley Hoffman thiab Nathan Otis sawv cev rau Campbell. Otis hu ua pawg txiav txim plaub ntug "kev lees paub txog qhov tsis txaus ntseeg thiab tsis paub tseeb tias kev tshawb fawb tiag tiag yog" nyob ib puag ncig kev raug mob taub hau. Nws hu ua qhov kev txiav txim siab tias "kev tsis lees paub lub tswv yim tias txhua yam uas qee tus neeg hais tias yog kev tsim txom lub taub hau tiag tiag yog, vim hmoov tsis zoo, qhov ntawd yog qhov koj pom tshwm sim ntau dhau lawm, thiab kuv zoo siab tias pawg neeg txiav txim tsis yooj yim swayed." 

Lub nonprofit Wisconsin Watch (ntawm wisconsinwatch.org) koom tes nrog Wisconsin Public Radio, PBS Wisconsin, lwm cov xov xwm tshaj tawm thiab Tsev Kawm Ntawv University of Wisconsin-Madison Kev Sau Ntawv thiab Kev Sib Txuas Lus. Txhua yam haujlwm tau tsim, tshaj tawm, tshaj tawm lossis tshaj tawm los ntawm Wisconsin Watch tsis tas yuav cuam tshuam cov kev xav lossis kev xav ntawm UW-Madison lossis ib qho ntawm cov koom tes.

Rov luam tawm peb cov ntawv dawb, hauv online lossis luam tawm, raws li daim ntawv tso cai Creative Commons.

Nrov dab neeg los ntawm Wisconsin Watch

Dee J. Hall / Wisconsin SaibTswj Editor

Dee J. Hall, tus tsim ntawm Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism, tau koom nrog cov neeg ua haujlwm ua tus tswj xyuas thaum Lub Rau Hli 2015. Nws yog lub luag haujlwm rau lub chaw haujlwm xov xwm txhua hnub. Nws tau ua haujlwm ntawm Wisconsin State Journal rau 24 xyoo ua tus editor thiab tus neeg sau xov xwm tsom mus rau cov haujlwm thiab kev tshawb nrhiav.

Ib xyoo 1982 kawm tiav ntawm Indiana University lub tsev kawm ntawv xov xwm, Hall tau tshaj tawm haujlwm ua haujlwm ntawm Lake County Star hauv Crown Point, Ind., The Gary (Ind.) Post-Tribune, The Louisville (Ky.) Times thiab St. Petersburg (Fla. .) Sijhawm. Ua ntej nws rov qab mus rau nws lub nroog Madison hauv xyoo 1990, nws yog tus neeg sau xov xwm rau yim xyoo ntawm Arizona Republic cov ntawv xov xwm hauv Phoenix, uas nws tau hais txog tsoomfwv hauv nroog, tsev kawm ntawv thiab ib puag ncig. Thaum nws 35-xyoo kev sau ntawv xov xwm, Hall tau yeej ntau dua peb lub zos, xeev thiab lub teb chaws khoom plig rau nws txoj haujlwm, suav nrog xyoo 2001 State Journal kev tshawb nrhiav uas tau nthuav tawm $ 4 lab-xyoo-laus lub tshuab zais cia ua haujlwm los ntawm Wisconsin cov thawj coj tsim cai lij choj.