Wisconsin Saib yog ib lub koom haum nonprofit, nonpartisan xov xwm. Subscribe rau peb ntawv xov xwm rau cov dab neeg qub thiab peb cov xov xwm hnub Friday roundup.
Thaum Ascension's St. Joseph Tsev Kho Mob hauv Milwaukee tshaj tawm tias nws yuav txiav cov kev pabcuam rov qab rau xyoo 2018, cov neeg nyob hauv thaj chaw Sherman Park nyob ib puag ncig balked.
Cov neeg dub feem ntau, cov neeg tau nyiaj tsawg hauv zej zog twb tau ntsib nws txoj kev sib tw. Ze li ntawm ib feem peb ntawm cov neeg nyob hauv ZIP code nyob hauv kev txom nyem, thiab cov me nyuam mos liab yug los muaj ntau dua ob zaug uas yuav tuag zoo li cov me nyuam mos dawb. Cov neeg nyob hauv ntshai tias kev txo cov kev pabcuam yuav ua rau muaj qhov tsis sib xws, thiab tseem ua rau lub tsev kho mob kaw tag nrho.
Lawv tau tawm tsam hnyav kom khaws cov kev pabcuam hauv chaw, thiab St. Joseph lub tuam txhab niam txiv, Ascension Wisconsin, thaum kawg muab cov txiav rau tuav. Tsev Kho Mob St. Joseph ua haujlwm los tuav lub zej zog txoj kev ntseeg siab thiab ua kom tiav cov kev xav tau ntawm kev sib raug zoo ntawm cov neeg mob, los ntawm cov kev pab cuam xws li Blanket of Love, uas qhia cov tsev neeg txog kev noj qab haus huv ua ntej yug menyuam, khoom noj khoom haus thiab kev tawm dag zog.
Reggie Newson, tus thawj coj tawm tswv yim ntawm Ascension Wisconsin hais tias "Nws yog ib lub chaw thauj tog rau nkoj.
Tab sis St. Joseph tseem yog lub hom phiaj ntawm kev tawm tsam sib txawv. Lub tsev kho mob yog Catholic, uas txhais tau tias nws ua raws Kev cai ncaj ncees thiab kev cai dab qhuas, cov txheej txheem sau los ntawm US Conference of Catholic Npis Sov. Cov kev cai txwv tsis pub tsev kho mob Catholic, tshwj tsis yog thaum muaj xwm txheej hnyav, los ntawm kev muab cov txheej txheem uas lub tsev teev ntuj pom tias ua tsis ncaj ncees - suav nrog kev rho menyuam, kev xeeb menyuam thiab kev ua kom tsis muaj menyuam. In-vitro fertilization raug txwv, ib yam li kws kho mob pab tua tus kheej uas raug cai hauv cuaj lub xeev thiab Cheeb Tsam Columbia, txawm tias tsis nyob hauv Wisconsin.
Asma Kadri Keeler, tus kws lij choj ua haujlwm ntawm ACLU ntawm Wisconsin, tsis ntev los no tau ntsib nrog cov tswv cuab ntawm St. Joe's Accountability Coalition, ib pab pawg neeg zej zog tsim tom qab Ascension tshaj tawm nws cov kev txiav tawm. Tom qab nws qhia lawv txog txoj cai hauv tsev kho mob Catholic, "Lub teeb taws tau tawm hauv chav," Keeler hais.
Txawm hais tias feem coob ntawm cov neeg tshawb fawb los ntawm pawg neeg zej zog muaj kev pom zoo ntawm St. Joseph, qee cov neeg nyob hauv tau hais rau Keeler tias lawv txhawj xeeb thiab tsis kam xa lawv cov neeg hlub uas cev xeeb tub mus rau tsev kho mob.
Keeler hais tias thaum ACLU ua haujlwm los tiv thaiv kev ntseeg kev ywj pheej, nws kuj tau foob thaum cov neeg mob tsis kam saib xyuas raws li kev txwv kev cai dab qhuas.
"Peb tuav txoj haujlwm uas nws (kev ntseeg kev ywj pheej) tsis tuaj yeem siv los ua phem rau lwm tus," nws hais.
Cov neeg tawm tswv yim txog txoj cai kev yug me nyuam hais tias cov kev txwv txwv kev cai dab qhuas rau cov neeg mob thiab ua txhaum cov qauv kev kho mob ntawm kev saib xyuas hauv txoj hauv kev uas cuam tshuam tsis zoo rau cov zej zog xws li Sherman Park.
Cov kab ke kev noj qab haus huv Catholic tau sib cav tias lawv ua haujlwm hauv kev nyab xeeb hauv cov zej zog txom nyem thiab muab kev saib xyuas zoo ib yam li cov tsev kho mob secular. Raws li lub koom haum Catholic Health Association (CHA), uas sawv cev thiab tawm tswv yim rau ntau tshaj 600 lub tsev kho mob Catholic hauv Tebchaws Meskas, cov neeg mob uas tau txais kev saib xyuas hauv tsev kho mob Catholic. muaj feem yuav pom zoo cov tsev kho mob tshaj cov neeg mob uas tau txais kev saib xyuas lwm qhov.
Tias St. Joseph yog ob qho tib si xav tau thiab raug thuam yog qhov cuam tshuam txog kev ntxhov siab ntau ntxiv rau cov zej zog. Kev tshuaj xyuas los ntawm Cap Times thiab Fuller Project, lub koom haum xov xwm tsis muaj txiaj ntsig tsom rau cov poj niam cov teeb meem, qhia tau hais tias hauv Wisconsin, cov tsev kho mob Catholic tau nce 13 feem pua, thaum cov tsev kho mob tsis yog Catholic poob los ntawm tib feem pua, ntawm 2001 thiab 2018.
Wisconsin cov tsev kho mob tuaj yeem ua cov kev hloov no nrog kev saib xyuas me ntsis - lossis xav txog qhov kev txiav txim siab ua lag luam yuav txwv tsis pub nkag mus rau cov kev pabcuam kho mob. Wisconsin yog ib qho ntawm 15 lub xeev uas tsis muaj txheej txheem los tswj kev nthuav dav hauv tsev kho mob lossis kev sib koom ua ke, feem ntau hu ua Daim Ntawv Pov Thawj Xav Tau.
Feem ntau, cov tsev kho mob Catholic, uas kho ib ntawm txhua xya Cov neeg mob hauv Tebchaws Meskas, txawv ntawm cov neeg nyob hauv lub npe nkaus xwb. Txawm li cas los xij, cov neeg thuam hais tias, nyob rau hauv ib qho me me tab sis tseem ceeb ntawm kev saib xyuas kev yug me nyuam, Catholic ethics tuaj yeem cuam tshuam kev kho mob zoo tshaj plaws, cov npis sov tuaj yeem cuam tshuam ntau dua li cov kws kho mob, thiab cov neeg mob tuaj yeem tsis lees txais kev saib xyuas lawv xav tau lossis xav tau.
Cov tsev kho mob Catholic feem ntau
Hauv Wisconsin, qhov chaw Catholic Germans thiab Irish tau tswj hwm kev tsiv teb tsaws chaw nyob rau nruab nrab mus txog lig-1800s, ib feem peb ntawm cov tsev kho mob tau tswj hwm los ntawm Catholic cov ntsiab cai - ntau dua ob npaug ntawm lub teb chaws nruab nrab.
Cov tsev kho mob tsis tshua muaj pob tshab txog cov kev pabcuam uas lawv yuav thiab yuav tsis muab, thiab cov neeg mob feem ntau tsis muaj kev xaiv ntawm qhov chaw lawv nrhiav kev saib xyuas - lossis kev saib xyuas lawv yuav tau txais, Cap Times thiab Fuller Project pom.
Wisconsin muaj kev vam khom ntau dua Catholic kev kho mob tshaj yuav luag lwm lub xeev hauv lub tebchaws. Nws yog tib lub xeev uas cov poj niam dub muaj feem ntau yuav xa lawv cov menyuam hauv ib lub koom haum Catholic dua li cov uas tsis yog-Catholic ib, Columbia Law School cov kws tshawb fawb pom. Thiab hauv 12 lub xeev Wisconsin 72 lub nroog, tib lub tsev kho mob nyob hauv ciam teb yog Catholic.
Cov tsev kho mob no tau tswj hwm los ntawm 77 cov lus qhia, uas fuse Catholic kev ntseeg nrog tshuaj thiab thev naus laus zis. Lawv tau nthuav tawm lub Koom Txoos Catholic lub zeem muag ntawm kev saib xyuas kev noj qab haus huv nyob rau niaj hnub nim no, suav nrog kev cog lus los ua haujlwm rau cov neeg nyob hauv cov npoo ntawm cov zej zog thiab cov cai rau yuav ua li cas cov tsev kho mob Catholic yuav tsum koom ua ke nrog cov tsis yog Catholic.
Ntau cov lus qhia hais txog kev tu menyuam yaus uas lub tsev teev ntuj hais tias tuaj yeem ua rau "kev sib raug zoo, kev puas siab puas ntsws thiab kev coj ncaj ncees" hauv kev sib yuav thiab tsev neeg. Piv txwv li, cov tsev kho mob uas koom nrog Catholic yuav tsis muab kev ua kom tsis muaj menyuam yog tias lub hom phiaj ib leeg yog los tiv thaiv tus poj niam cev xeeb tub.
Thiab tsis pub rho menyuam tawm, tshwj tsis yog tias nws yog qhov "tsis tuaj yeem zam" qhov tshwm sim ntawm kev nqis tes ua los cawm leej niam txoj sia, raws li Brian Reardon, tus lwm thawj ntawm kev sib txuas lus thiab kev lag luam rau CHA.
Cov tsev kho mob tuaj yeem sib txawv ntawm cov lus qhia txhais tau li cas, nrog rau qee qhov kev siv kev ua haujlwm, xws li Madison, Wisconsin, lub tsev kho mob uas hais txog cov neeg mob nrhiav kev ua kom tsis muaj menyuam kom ua raws li cov txheej txheem ntawm lub chaw kho qhov muag nyob ze uas ua kev phais. Hauv lwm qhov xwm txheej, kev ua raws li Catholic cov lus qhia tau ua rau muaj kev tsis lees paub thiab ncua sij hawm uas cov kws kho mob hais tias ua rau poj niam txoj kev noj qab haus huv muaj kev pheej hmoo.
Txoj cai Catholic txhais li cas nws txawv ntawm lub tsev kho mob thiab koj tus kws kho mob twg. Qee tus kws kho mob muab kev xa mus rau kev rho menyuam thiab lwm yam kev pabcuam txwv lossis nrhiav kev ua haujlwm rau cov cai Catholic, xws li sau tshuaj tiv thaiv kab mob rau poj niam cev xeeb tub es tsis yog kev yug menyuam. Lwm tus ua raws li cov lus qhia nruj me ntsis.
Tawm ntawm kaum ob tus neeg kho mob yav dhau los thiab tam sim no, kws kho mob, kws saib xyuas neeg mob thiab tus kws yug menyuam hauv Wisconsin tau hu los ntawm Cap Times thiab Fuller Project, tsuas yog ib tus kws kho mob tam sim no tau pom zoo los hais hauv cov ntaub ntawv rau zaj dab neeg no. Lwm tus kws kho mob tam sim no tau pom zoo hais lus tsis qhia npe vim yog kev txhawj xeeb txog kev cuam tshuam tsis zoo rau lawv txoj haujlwm lossis vim tias lawv tau raug qhia kom tsis txhob los ntawm lawv qhov chaw ua haujlwm.
Tawm tswv yim txog qhov sib txawv ntawm kev ua raws li Catholic lub hauv paus ntsiab lus, ib tug Milwaukee obstetrician uas thov kom tsis txhob muaj npe hais tias: "Nws nyuaj heev vim koj tsis paub tias koj tab tom ua dab tsi ntawm cov tsev kho mob sib txawv nrog ntau txoj cai. Raws li qhov tsis txaus ntseeg, nws yuav luag zoo li lawv muaj kev ntseeg sib txawv. "
Kom paub meej tias Wisconsin lub tsev kho mob Catholic txhais li cas, siv thiab sib txuas lus cov lus qhia, Cap Times thiab Fuller Project tau xa cov lus nug mus rau rau lub tsev kho mob li no: Ascension, SSM Health, Tsev Kho Mob Sisters Health System, Divine Savior Healthcare, Essentia Health, thiab Tsev Neeg Dawb Huv Memorial. Cov lus nug tseem raug xa mus rau Aspirus thiab Mayo Clinic Health System-Franciscan Healthcare, ob lub tsev kho mob uas tsis yog Catholic uas muaj cov tsev kho mob uas ua raws li ERDs.
Tsis muaj leej twg teb tus kheej. Txawm li cas los xij, Nathaniel Blanton Hibner, CHA tus thawj coj ntawm kev coj ncaj ncees, tau xa ib nqe lus los sawv cev ntawm lub koom haum thiab Ascension, SSM thiab Tsev Kho Mob Sisters Health System:
"Cov kws kho mob ua haujlwm hauv cov chaw Catholic tuaj yeem thiab sau tshuaj tiv thaiv kab mob los kho ntau yam mob hauv qab no," Hibner tau sau. “Lub tsev kho mob Catholic tseem muab tshuaj tiv thaiv xwm txheej ceev rau cov neeg raug tsim txom los yog raug yuam deev. … Cov tsev kho mob Catholic kuj tsis muab cov txheej txheem xaiv uas lub hom phiaj yog los ua kom tsis muaj menyuam. "
Daim ntawv qhia tag nrho tuaj yeem nyeem ntawm no.
Tus kws kho mob rov qab muaj peev xwm 'lub sijhawm foob pob'
Dr. Kathy Hartke ua haujlwm hauv tsev kho mob Catholic tau 27 xyoo. Nws nco qab ib tus neeg mob los ntawm ntau xyoo dhau los uas nws hais tias tau cuam tshuam tsis zoo los ntawm cov lus qhia.
Ib tug poj niam cev xeeb tub nrog menyuam ntxaib tuaj txog ntawm tsev kho mob Catholic hauv Brookfield, tam sim no hu ua Ascension SE Wisconsin Hospital-Elmbrook Campus. Nws cov dej tau tawg, thiab nws pib ua haujlwm ua haujlwm. Txog li 21 lub lis piam, cov fetuses tsis muaj feem yuav muaj sia nyob.
Qhov ntev lawv tos kom txiav cev xeeb tub thiab nws lub tsev me nyuam tseem nthuav dav, qhov kev pheej hmoo ntau dua tus poj niam lub tsev menyuam yuav kis tau, Hartke tau hais. Tab sis ntawm Elmbrook, cov neeg ua haujlwm kho mob tau hais tias lawv tsis tuaj yeem txiav cev xeeb tub yog tias cov menyuam hauv plab muaj lub plawv dhia.
Hartke pom zoo kom tus neeg mob raug xa mus rau lub tsev kho mob Secular Waukesha Memorial, qhov chaw uas lawv tuaj yeem ua rau muaj zog. Tab sis cov kws saib xyuas neeg mob tau muab cov lus qhia tawm rau tus neeg mob, hais tias lub tsev kho mob Catholic yuav saib xyuas nws zoo.
"Lub sijhawm no, peb tab tom zaum ntawm lub sijhawm foob pob ntawm qee tus neeg uas yuav mob hnyav, mob hnyav ... thiab muaj feem yuav tuag," Hartke, uas tau so haujlwm los ntawm kev xyaum hais.
Tau txais cov lus sib xyaw thiab tsis paub tias yuav tso siab rau leej twg, tus neeg mob tseem nyob hauv Hartke txoj kev saib xyuas. Hnub tom qab ntawd, tus neeg mob tau mob hnyav thiab mob. Nws thiaj li tsim tau tus kab mob sepsis, tus mob ua rau muaj kev phom sij rau lub neej uas yog lub cev teb rau kev kis kab mob, Hartke nco qab.
Hmoov zoo, tus neeg mob tsis tuag. Hartke hais tias thaum kawg nws tau mus ua haujlwm tsis tu ncua thiab tau muab tshuaj tua kab mob, uas tiv thaiv nws kom tsis txhob mob hnyav. Cov fetuses tsis ciaj sia.
Yog tias leej niam raug mob los ntawm kev ua phem rau lub neej, cov tsev kho mob Catholic yuav muab txhua yam kev kho mob qhia - txawm tias nws ua rau tus menyuam tuag, CHA's Hibner hais.
"Kuv tau hu mus rau qhov chaw kws kho mob yuav hais tias, 'Zoo, peb xav tias muaj txoj hauv kev zoo rau kev kis tus kab mob tab sis peb yuav tos," "" ntxiv rau Rev. Charles Bouchard, tus thawj coj loj ntawm kev ntseeg ntawm CHA. “Thiab kuv xav hais tias, 'Saib, tsis txhob tos kom txog thaum tus kab mob no pib. Koj yuav tsum ceev faj txog qhov no vim koj paub tias nws yuav mus qhov twg.' ”
Tab sis hauv nws qhov kev paub, Hartke hais tias, "lawv thawb nws mus rau qhov kawg thib ob."
"Yuav ua li cas tus kws kho mob yuav tsum muaj peev xwm kwv yees thaum nws lig dhau lawm thiab ib tug poj niam yuav tuag?" nws hais.
Cov teeb meem ntawm cev xeeb tub lig, thaum tsis tshua muaj, tuaj yeem tsim teeb meem rau qee tus poj niam nrhiav kev saib xyuas hauv tsev kho mob Catholic, hais tias Dr. Jessika Ralph, tus qub neeg nyob hauv Medical College of Wisconsin uas tig los ntawm ob lub tsev kho mob Milwaukee Catholic. Tus kws kho mob obstetrician / gynecologist, Ralph tam sim no ua haujlwm ntawm University of Minnesota Health.
Ralph tau sim ua kom yooj yim rau kev rho menyuam rau tus neeg mob uas tau mob tom qab mus rau kev ua haujlwm ntxov ntxov nrog menyuam ntxaib ntawm St. Joseph xyoo 2017. Ralph hais tias nws raug yuam kom tos kom txog thaum tus poj niam hemorrhages lossis pom cov tsos mob ntawm tus kab mob los pab kom xaus lub cev xeeb tub.
Thawj fetus nchuav menyuam, thiab rau ntau teev, tus neeg mob los ntshav hnyav thiab ntws tawm ntawm cov xim. Thaum tus poj niam qhov kub thiab txias tau nce siab tom qab 10 teev, Ralph hais tias nws tau muab tshuaj los ua kom muaj zog - tab sis tsis yog tus qauv rho menyuam tawm tshuaj mifepristone, uas lub tsev kho mob tsis tau npaj. Tus fetus thib ob tau yug los 24 teev tom qab tus poj niam tau txais, Ralph hais tias, thiab tsis muaj sia nyob.
"Txawm hais tias tag nrho kuv ntseeg tias cov tsev kho mob no muab kev saib xyuas obstetric thiab gynecological zoo rau cov poj niam, qhov no hmoov tsis yog qhov sib txawv loj heev, thiab nws yog qhov sib txawv uas cov neeg mob tsis paub txog," hais Ralph, uas tau hais rau nws zaj dab neeg rau. Rewire. Xov xwm. "Kuv xav kom cov neeg mob paub tias qhov no yog qhov tshwm sim tiag tiag uas qee zaum lub tsev kho mob tsis tuaj yeem muab kev saib xyuas uas koj xav tias koj xav tau."
Tubal ligations tsa teeb meem pos
Ntawm ib lub tsev kho mob Catholic hauv Milwaukee, cov kws kho mob "tsis tu ncua" khiav mus rau cov kev txwv no thaum muab kev saib xyuas rau lawv cov neeg mob, hais tias tus kws kho menyuam yaus uas xav tsis qhia npe.
Tus kws kho mob hais tias qee cov txheej txheem Catholic txwv tsis pub, xws li khi tus poj niam cov hlab ntsha tom qab nws xa tawm ntawm C-section los tiv thaiv kev xeeb tub ntxiv, yog li nquag thov kom cov kws kho mob tau ploj mus txog pes tsawg zaus lawv yuav tsum tsis kam lees lawv.
Hom kev ua kom tsis muaj menyuam no yog ib hom kev tiv thaiv kab mob, nrog ib nrab ntawm tag nrho cov txheej txheem no tau ua sai sai tom qab tus poj niam yug, raws li kev kawm los ntawm Nan O'Connell, tus pab xibfwb hauv Department of Obstetrics thiab Gynecology ntawm Virginia Commonwealth University School of Medicine.
Cov poj niam xa los ntawm C-section ntawm lub tsev kho mob secular tuaj yeem hais kom cov kws kho mob khi lawv cov hlab ntsha, txiav lawv thiab ua kom qhov kawg thaum lub plab tseem qhib - cov txheej txheem uas yuav kav ntev li ob peb feeb.
Tab sis ntawm lub tsev kho mob Catholic, tib tus poj niam yuav tsum teem caij phais thib ob ntawm lub tsev kho mob txawv, Milwaukee kws kho mob hais tias. Thaum tus poj niam npaj txhij mus rau hauv qab riam, nws kuj yuav xeeb tub dua.
Qhov tseeb, cov kws tshawb fawb tau pom tias ze li ib nrab ntawm cov poj niam uas tau thov kom tsis muaj menyuam tab sis raug tsis pom zoo tau xeeb tub. tsis pub dhau ib xyoos.
"Lawv tau ua tiav (muaj menyuam) tab sis lawv tsis muaj peev xwm rov qab los thiab teeb tsa lwm qhov kev phais," tus kws kho mob hais.
Cov tsev kho mob tseem them nqi ze li peb npaug ntau dua rau kev sib kis tom qab yug me nyuam ntau dua li lawv ua rau tib txoj kev ua thaum lub sij hawm C-section, raws li cov npe txheej txheem cov nqi them rau 13 ntawm 15 Aurora tsev kho mob hauv Wisconsin. Tus nqi nruab nrab rau C-section tubal yog $ 515, thaum tus nqi rau tus menyuam tom qab yug menyuam yog $ 1,390.
Txawm hais tias nws yog ib qho txheej txheem ib hnub feem ntau ua nyob rau hauv qhov chaw kho mob, tom qab yug tubals koom nrog txaus ntshai rau tej kev phais, nrog rau kev kis kab mob, los ntshav thiab qhov tsis zoo ntawm cov tshuaj loog.
Rau cov poj niam uas muaj teeb meem kev noj qab haus huv loj, xws li kab mob plawv lossis mob ntshav qab zib mellitus, kev xeeb tub dua tuaj yeem ua rau tuag taus. Txawm hais tias kev tuag tsis tshua muaj, Wisconsin cov poj niam dub yog tsib zaug yuav tuag vim cev xeeb tub tshaj cov poj niam dawb, thiab lub xeev muaj ntau tshaj tus me nyuam mos tuag tus nqi rau cov me nyuam mos dub nyob hauv tebchaws.
Cov kws kho mob hauv tsev kho mob Catholic ntsib teeb meem: Xa cov neeg mob mus rau lwm lub tsev kho mob thiab txiav lawv cov kev coj ua, ua cov tubal ligation thiab pheej hmoo ua txhaum lub tsev kho mob cov cai, lossis ua rau tus neeg mob mus txog ob qho kev phais, ntawm ob qhov chaw sib txawv.
"Thaum koj muaj kev tsis sib haum xeeb zoo li ntawd, nws yuav noj rau koj," Hartke, tus kws kho mob laus laus hais.
Milwaukee obstetrician tam sim no qhia cov neeg mob kom tsis txhob xa mus tom tsev kho mob Catholic yog tias lawv xav tau tubal ligation. Tus kws kho mob hais tias nws tsis tsim nyog rau kev pheej hmoo.
Kev ntseeg kev ntseeg tsis yog ib txwm meej
Thiab ntau tus neeg uas tau txais kev saib xyuas hauv tsev kho mob Catholic tsis paub txog nws txoj kev ntseeg. Hauv ib teb daim ntawv ntsuam xyuas, ib feem peb ntawm cov poj niam hnub nyoog 18 txog 45 xyoo uas tau hu lub chaw Catholic ua lawv lub tsev kho mob tseem ceeb rau kev yug me nyuam tsis paub tias yog Catholic.
Hartke hais tias "Tsis muaj qhov pom tseeb,"
Ib tug poj niam hais tias nws tau ntau xyoo tom qab thaum nws pom cov lus qhia tau cuam tshuam rau nws. Tom qab xa nws tus ntxhais hauv Tsev Kho Mob Sacred Heart hauv Eau Claire hauv 1990, Melissa Davies xav tau tubal ligation.
"Kuv hais tias qhov no yuav yog kuv tus menyuam nkaus xwb thiab thov kom muab kuv txoj hlua khi," Davies, uas muaj 24 xyoo thaum ntawd.
Nws hais tias cov neeg ua haujlwm hauv tsev kho mob tsis kam lees nws qhov kev thov, qhia nws tias nws tseem hluas dhau thiab tias txoj haujlwm tsis raug cai.
"Tom qab ntawd kuv los paub tias nws yog txoj cai Catholic, tsis yog txoj cai tiag," nws hais.
Muam Mary Haddad, tus thawj tswj hwm thiab CEO ntawm CHA, tsis lees paub qhov kev xav tias cov tsev kho mob no sim zais lawv txoj kev koom nrog Catholic.
"Yog tias muaj dab tsi, peb niaj hnub nrhiav kev sib txuas lus li ntawd rau pej xeem," nws hais.
Xyaum, txoj cai tshwm rau diverge
Compounding qhov tsis meej pem yog qhov tseeb tias kev xyaum tsis ib txwm tshwm sim raws li txoj cai teev tseg. Piv txwv li, cov kws kho mob ntawm SSM Health St. Mary's Tsev Kho Mob hauv Madison ua cov hlab ntsha ntawm SSM's Davis Duehr Dean Eye Care, ib lub tsev kho mob nyob ze yav dhau los ua haujlwm los ntawm Secular Dean Health Systems.
Raws li tus kws saib xyuas neeg mob uas ua haujlwm rau Dean, lub tsev kho mob tau teeb tsa rau kev phais qhov muag tab sis tsis yog rau tubals, thiab qee zaum nws tsis muaj cov khoom siv tsim nyog. Nws nco qab tus kws kho mob hais rau nws tias nws yuav tsum tau taug kev ntawm qhov chaw kho qhov muag thiab tsev kho mob kom tau txais cov khoom siv xav tau.
Tus kws saib xyuas neeg mob, uas tau thov kom tsis qhia npe, hais tias lwm tus neeg ua haujlwm hauv tsev kho mob xav tsis thoob vim li cas lawv tsis tuaj yeem ua tubals hauv St. Mary lub chaw phais thiab chaw zov me nyuam nyob ze, qhov chaw uas lwm hnub tau ua. St. Mary's tsis teb rau qhov kev thov tawm tswv yim.
Tab sis Dr. Doug Laube, yav dhau los tus thawj tswj hwm ntawm American College of Obstetricians thiab Gynecologists thiab tus kws tshaj lij so haujlwm thiab kws kho mob hauv University of Wisconsin-Madison, tau lees paub tias tubals tau ua nyob rau ntawd. Nws hu txoj kev npaj "irrational."
Nws tsis paub meej tias cov kev npaj zoo sib xws yuav raug tso cai mus tom ntej, raws li kws lij choj ntawm lub National Health Law Program, uas ua haujlwm los tiv thaiv txoj cai saib xyuas kev noj qab haus huv ntawm cov neeg tsis tau txais kev pab. Xyoo 2018, Tebchaws Asmeskas Lub Rooj Sib Tham ntawm Catholic Npis Sov tau hloov kho cov lus qhia los qhia txog kev sib koom ua ke hauv tsev kho mob, sau tias cov kev npaj "yuav tsum tau ua tiav raws li kev qhia ncaj ncees ntawm lub Koom Txoos Catholic."
Cov kws kho mob St. Mary kuj tseem tuaj yeem ua tubal ligations thaum lub sijhawm C-section, ib tus neeg nyob hauv yav dhau los hais tias - sib piv rau ntau lub tsev kho mob Catholic, uas tsis muaj kev pabcuam ntawd.
Raws li yav tas los UW-Madison obstetrics/gynecology neeg nyob, cov kws kho mob ntawm St. Mary's tuaj yeem sau ntawv mus rau cov thawj coj sib cav tias nws muaj kev nyab xeeb dua rau leej niam tsis txhob muaj menyuam ntxiv, xws li hauv cov xwm txheej uas muaj C-section. ua rau lawv muaj kev pheej hmoo siab ntawm cov teeb meem. Tsab ntawv xav zoo li kev cai thiab tau pom zoo txhua zaus, tus neeg nyob hauv yav dhau los nco qab.
Txoj cai tswj kev tiv thaiv kab mob sib txawv
Ib qho kev txwv nruj dua yog cov ntawv tswj kev yug menyuam uas lawv tuaj yeem muab tau, tus neeg nyob hauv yav dhau los hais. Cov tsev kho mob hauv tsev kho mob feem ntau cog cov tshuaj tiv thaiv kab mob ntev ntev xws li intrauterine devices (IUDs) tom qab tus poj niam yug me nyuam. Cov kws kho mob tau xam phaj los ntawm Cap Times thiab Fuller Project uas ua haujlwm hauv tsev kho mob Catholic hais tias lawv tsis raug tso cai rau cog IUDs, uas muab kev tiv thaiv kab mob uas tuaj yeem kav ntev xyoo.
Cov ntaub ntawv los ntawm Wisconsin Tsev Kho Mob Association qhia tias qhov no muaj tseeb ntau. Piv txwv li, Ascension's St. Joseph Tsev Kho Mob, tau them nyiaj rau IUD tsuas yog cuaj zaug rau xyoo nyiaj txiag xaus rau Lub Rau Hli 2019, thaum lub tsev kho mob uas tsis yog Catholic Froedtert Memorial Lutheran, tsawg dua 5 mais deb, ua tib yam ntau dua 1,500 zaug.
Muaj qee qhov tshwj xeeb tseem ceeb. Essentia Health St. Mary's Hospital-Superior tau them nqi rau 135 IUDs hauv xyoo 2019; Ascension All Saints Hospital in Racine, uas muaj ob lub tsev kawm ntawv, sau nqi rau 666 IUDs, Wisconsin Hospital Association cov ntaub ntawv qhia.
Lub sijhawm tam sim tom qab yug me nyuam tuaj yeem yog qhov tseem ceeb los tshem tawm qhov tsis sib haum xeeb rau cov neeg uas xav tau. Plaub caug feem pua ntawm cov poj niam tsis txhob rov qab mus xyuas tom qab yug me nyuam, thaum ntau npaum li 75 feem pua ntawm cov poj niam uas npaj yuav tau txais cov tshuaj tiv thaiv ntev ntev tom qab yug me nyuam tsis ua raws li.
"Nws yog lub sijhawm uas tsis muaj tseeb," tus kws saib xyuas neeg mob qub Dean hais.
Cami Thomas piv xws li kev cai dab qhuas tsis kam saib xyuas rau lub teb chaws txoj kev txaj muag keeb kwm ntawm cov neeg xim sterilized tiv thaiv lawv lub siab nyiam uas txuas ntxiv mus rau xyoo pua dhau los. Thomas yog ib tug thawj coj ntawm Maroon Calabash, uas piav qhia nws tus kheej tias yog lub koom haum dub radical kev ncaj ncees kev yug me nyuam los ntawm doulas uas muab kev txhawb nqa thiab kev taw qhia rau cov poj niam cev xeeb tub.
Lwm yam kev tshawb fawb tau pom tias cov poj niam ntawm cov xim ntau dua xav tias cov kws kho mob tau siv tshuaj tiv thaiv ntau dua li cov poj niam dawb.
Kev saib xyuas menyuam yaus, nws hais tias, yuav tsum yog "kev hwm thiab kev pom zoo."
Thomas hais rov qab mus rau lub tsev kho mob Catholic txog ib xyoo caum dhau los thaum nws nyob rau ntawm txoj kev tuag, tau poob ob feem peb ntawm nws cov ntshav tom qab nws kev coj khaub ncaws mus rau rau lub hlis.
Txhawm rau txwv nws lub sijhawm thiab coj nws cov ntshav suav, nws tus kws kho mob xav muab nws Depo-Provera, tshuaj tiv thaiv kab mob, nws hais. Tab sis lub tsev kho mob cov cai ntawm kev tiv thaiv kab mob txwv tsis pub nws, tus kws kho mob hais rau nws. Kev npau taws ntawm tsev kho mob cov cai, nws pom muaj qhov tsis zoo.
"Tsis yog txhua tus kws kho mob zoo li ntawd," nws hais. “Ua tsaug uas kuv muaj tus kws kho mob ntawd.”
Zaj dab neeg no yog kev sib koom tes ntawm Wisconsin Watch, Cap Times thiab Fuller Project, ib lub koom haum tsis koom nrog, cov xov xwm tsis muaj txiaj ntsig uas tsom mus rau cov poj niam cov teeb meem. Lub koom haum saib xyuas tsis tau nyiaj Wisconsin (www.WisconsinWatch.org) koom teg nrug Wisconsin Public Radio, Wisconsin Public TV, lwm qhov xov xwm thiab University of Wisconsin-Madison Tsev Kawm Ntawv Xov Xwm thiab Kev Sib Txuas Lus. Txhua yam haujlwm tau tsim, tshaj tawm, tshaj tawm lossis tshaj tawm los ntawm Wisconsin Watch tsis tas yuav cuam tshuam cov kev xav lossis kev xav ntawm UW-Madison lossis ib qho ntawm cov koom tes.
Rov luam tawm peb cov ntawv dawb, hauv online lossis luam tawm, raws li daim ntawv tso cai Creative Commons.
