February 13, 2011

Deer, coyotes and turkeys, oh my!

"We thought we missed him. And then we heard the clunk," Merrill resident Karen Drost says of the July 28, 2010 collision of a Cessna 210 piloted by her husband, Doug, with a deer at the Shell Lake airport in northwestern Wisconsin. The plane, not shown, received $12,000 in damage. Photo courtesy of Xai Kha/Wausau Daily Herald.


National coverage

Aviation database reveals frequent safety problems at airports Feb. 17, 2011: Summary of our collaborative investigation of NASA data


Smash hits: Pilots’ close encounters with large wildlife

Interviews and government databases recount dramatic stories of wildlife-plane collisions in Wisconsin. Frequent motifs: Animals that come out of nowhere or head toward the plane. Click to expand each example below.
— Kate Golden and Allie Tempus

[DDET Plane hits deer, tips over, lands on prop]
“Had started my takeoff roll when at least three deer ran onto the runway. I immediately closed the throttle, applied brakes and full back on the yoke. The airplane skidded though I maintained directional control. One deer passed under my left wing. At the end of the skid, the airplane tipped forward, causing the propeller to contact the runway and the airplane rested on the prop. Afterwards I learned that it has happened several times when deer have been on the runway. I believe the brush and grass should be removed or mowed for some distance from the runway. Further, a tall fence may help.”

— Source: Aviation Safety Reporting System (ASRS) anonymous report, February 1995, at Blackhawk Airfield, 10 miles east of Madison. The FAA directory still warns pilots of deer, turkeys, brush and trees.


[DDET Winner: Most costly reported strike in Wisconsin]
“Hit 2 deer. Nose gear doors both curled back on leading edges, left main landing gear door was ripped off hinges, right wing leading edge dented, right wing flap buckled beyond repair … radome (radar enclosure in nose of plane) cracked and damaged; had to be replaced.”

— FAA Wildlife Strike Database account of a January 2001 hit involving a Learjet at Reedsburg Municipal Airport that caused $110,000 in damage.


[DDET Plane vs. coyote: coyote loses]
“Coyote was seen on left side of runway during landing rollout. Coyote darted to the right and was struck by the nose gear. No damage, just a big mess to clean up. This could have been more serious if there were more than one coyote or if we were departing.”

— ASRS report of a July 1996 incident at Waukesha County Airport.


[DDET Turkeys, en masse, make bad decision]
“Just after takeoff, 20-25 turkeys suddenly appeared just above the runway from left to right. Three were hit, mostly by strut and leading edge of wing.”

— FAA report of a September 2004 incident at Adams County Legion Field.


[DDET Deer punches hole in airplane wing]
“We were landing, we never even saw the thing. We heard it. … He hit the plane lights. We were on the ground, and it was dark out. We got back to the hangar … and I thought, ‘Boy, something doesn’t look right on the flap.’ … It had punched a hole on the wing and then it must’ve hit the ground and bounced up and came up on the flap. … The propeller got (the deer) and it basically decapitated it. … We didn’t even know it was deer, because it happened so quick. We had thought it was geese.”

— Interview with Jim Retzlaff, West Bend Municipal Airport manager, on a collision with two deer about 10 years ago


[DDET Instructor takes over plane in a hurry]
“I was flying with a customer. … I was the instructor pilot with him. And out of the corner of my eye, I caught two deer charging right at the airplane at dusk as we landed. And the pilot flying actually didn’t see the deer — they were coming up my side of the aircraft. So I took over control of the airplane and told him, ‘I have the airplane.’ … I tried to avoid them, missed one of them but got the other one.”

— Jeff Baum, Watertown Municipal Airport manager, on a crash there about six years ago


Large wildlife pose persistent, under-reported danger to Wisconsin pilots

Just as Doug Drost was landing at the Shell Lake airport, his wife, Karen Drost, saw something hurtling out of the darkness toward their Cessna 210. Something big. “Deer, deer, deer!” she screamed.

“He just came running full bore,” she said. “It’s not like a car, where you can hit your brakes. We thought we missed him. And then we heard the clunk.”

That July 28, 2010 hit on the northwestern Wisconsin runway — which caused $12,000 in damage — is a story that plays out over and over in this increasingly deer-ridden country.

Since the “Miracle on the Hudson” emergency landing of a U.S. Airways jet two years ago, the danger that birds pose to aircraft has become common knowledge nationwide. Pilots report thousands of bird strikes a year.

But there’s a lesser-known threat from other wildlife, and it varies from state to state: Texas has a bat problem, while Florida pilots have hit dozens of turtles and alligators. In Wisconsin, it’s deer.

Deer strikes are comparatively rare, but when deer and aircraft do collide, look out. In Alabama in 2001, a Learjet hit two deer and burst into flames, injuring both pilots.

Nationally, deer strikes accounted for about 10 percent of the hits that caused substantial damage to a plane since 1990, according to the Federal Aviation Administration’s Wildlife Strike Database.

By contrast, in Wisconsin, 54 percent of the reported crashes causing substantial damage involved deer. The others were mostly geese and gulls.

In all, there were 50 deer strikes or near-misses accounting for just 4 percent of all 1,155 wildlife incidents in the state since 1990. Yet the deer collisions accounted for two-thirds of all reported damage costs.

Screamers and bangers

Airport managers often use noisemakers like these "screamers" and "bangers" to scare large wildlife off the runways. Kate Golden/WCIJ

Airport managers all over Wisconsin said deer and other large animals, including coyotes and turkeys, have been a persistent problem over the years.

For some managers, wildlife on the runway is their number-one safety concern. They’ve resorted to sharpshooters, cannons, even a bushel of apples outside the airport fence. Tall fencing, a more permanent solution, is costly — and sometimes isn’t added until after a big accident has already happened.

“At all airports, virtually all airports, you always have to be on the lookout for wildlife,” said pilot and Watertown Municipal Airport Manager Jeff Baum, one of the 15 airport managers interviewed for this report. “Personally, I’ve hit deer, I’ve hit fox, I’ve hit pheasants, I’ve hit geese, ducks.”

Ed Simpson, manager of the Camp Lake airport in Kenosha County, said, “In rutting season, it (deer) is probably the highest risk. When they’re running around in love, they don’t watch things.”

Deer strikes: Damaging, and under-reported

Over the past few decades, air traffic has risen while the U.S. deer population has more than doubled.

One-third of Wisconsin’s 133 public airports are listed in FAA records with standing warnings about deer in the area. The Burnett County Airport in Siren lists bear as one of the wildlife hazards.

“Probably the most dangerous issues we face here are animals,” said Mike McCord, manager of the Clintonville Municipal Airport in Waupaca County.

Yet most wildlife strikes are never reported to FAA’s voluntary database, researchers say.

The FAA estimates 61 percent of strikes aren’t reported. General-aviation airports, which serve smaller aircraft, are thought to have the lowest rate of reporting — and are the most common type of airport in deer-dense areas of Wisconsin.

For instance, in March 1999, a small business aircraft hit a herd of deer at dusk at Superior’s Richard I. Bong Airport, causing $8,000 in damage. The account said it was the sixth deer strike there in the past 10 years. But it’s the only one listed in the FAA database.

Johnson Insurance Service Vice President Jeff Rasmussen said his company, which insures about 15 percent of the registered aircraft in Wisconsin, gets one or two claims each year for damage from wildlife strikes.

Jeff Skiles, U.S. Airways pilot

Oregon, Wis., resident Jeff Skiles co-piloted the 2009 U.S. Airways flight that landed dramatically in the Hudson River after geese flew into its engines. But he says he's never encountered deer on Wisconsin runways. Allie Tempus/WCIJ

Wisconsin pilots know to take an extra pass at certain airports to see what might be running across the tarmac. But that strategy is not infallible, as Ron Purvis knows.

Over the years, the Boyceville-based pilot has hit two deer, a turkey and an eagle, the latter two with student pilots at the controls.

And recently, he said, “Three deer ran across from us, and we slid to a stop. We ended up crossways across the runway. … Once that happens, you’re just along for the ride.”

Few wildlife strikes are as dramatic as what Jeff Skiles, the Oregon, Wis., co-pilot of the “Miracle on the Hudson” flight, experienced. A flock of geese flew into the U.S. Airways jet engines in January 2009, forcing the pilots and their 155 passengers to land on the water in New York City.

Closer to home, Skiles said, he’s never seen any deer on the small airport where he keeps his personal plane. “I’ve never known anybody that ran into a deer, either,” he said.

Markano with noisemaker

Waukesha County Airport Manager Keith Markano keeps a small pistol and a stash of noisemakers known as "screamers" and "bangers" in his airport truck, in case an errant deer or coyote is seen on the runway. Kate Golden/WCIJ

Screamers, bangers and fences

Airport managers from many small airports said they periodically hop in their trucks and drive down runways to scare off wildlife before clearing a plane to land. Even then, the pesky animals sometimes wander right back on.

Managers have developed quite an arsenal to deal with them.

Many have pyrotechnic noisemakers, shot out of a small pistol, known as “screamers” and “bangers.” Some use remote-controlled cannons. With permits, they also can shoot wildlife. Sharpshooters have taken 85 deer from the Portage Municipal Airport over the past decade, manager John Poppy said.

Most of these options require people to be present at the airport. But small airports and airstrips sometimes are unattended, leaving pilots to wait out or scare off the deer themselves.

Fences, though expensive, are the best defense.

“Our fencing has done wonders,” said McCord of Clintonville, which got a $275,000 fence in 2002. “Before that, the wildlife could come and go as they pleased.”

But many small airports and airstrips in Wisconsin are unfenced — sometimes by choice, to make them welcoming to the community, and sometimes because of cost.

Poppy said he can set his watch by the turkeys that cross the unfenced Portage airport runway twice a day. The airport has seen several strikes — Poppy himself once had to swerve around deer after touching down. But because the city plans to build a new airport, the current facility probably won’t be getting a fence, he said.

And those barriers are far from impenetrable. At Clintonville, the latest deer-aircraft collision was the day after Thanksgiving.

Waukesha County Airport's new fence, with deer habitat

Waukesha County Airport Manager Keith Markano used to see deer spring over the six-foot fence "like it was nothing." Last fall, the sections near deer habitat — which is seen on the right in December 2010 — were replaced with more deer-proof 10-foot fencing. Kate Golden/WCIJ

Mitigation may take years

For years, Waukesha County Airport Manager Keith Markano routinely saw deer hop over the 6-foot fence there “like it was nothing.”

In 1996, a Learjet pilot hit a coyote while landing at Waukesha and reported it to NASA’s Aviation Safety Reporting System, where pilots anonymously log all sorts of safety problems. It was the first of two plane-coyote hits that day at Waukesha, the NASA safety analyst discovered.

Deer tracks outside the Waukesha County Airport

Just outside the Waukesha County Airport fence in December 2010, fresh snow reveals many a deer track. Kate Golden/WCIJ

The pilot complained that “coyotes and deer have been a problem at this airport for many years” and speculated that “it will take a major accident to get any action.”

Last fall, Waukesha finally replaced some of its short fence with 10-foot-tall sections, at least in the spots where airport meets deer habitat.

Markano is pleased. He said animals have been scarce on the grounds since the taller fence went in. But he knows that no matter how tall the fence is, the coyotes could still dig under it.

The nonprofit Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism (www.WisconsinWatch.org) collaborates with Wisconsin Public Television, Wisconsin Public Radio, the UW-Madison School of Journalism & Mass Communication, and other news media. Kate Golden is at kgolden@wisconsinwatch.org.